Pages

Monday, December 22, 2014

ANALYSIS OF LAST YEARS REAL ESTATE FORECAST

FORECAST IN BLACK

ANALYSIS IN BLUE

2014 - The Year Ahead

(Indian Real Estate Scene in the first quarter of 2014)

The consensus of opinion on IREF is that the slowdown of 2013 will continue well into 2014. All the factors which caused the bear market of 2013 are even more active in 2014. Until the economy turns around, the industrial recession gets over, the job market recovers and inflation is controlled, the bear market will continue.

Came True


NCR market:The main Delhi market dominated by builder floors has seen actual reduction in prices from the peak by upto 30% in some areas. Dwarka which is one of the large micromarkets within Delhi dominated by apartments has also seen reduction in prices. Now that the correction is over, 2014 is likely to see stagnant prices.

Came True and prices continued to show mild decline in 2014 as well

In Gurgaon, the resale market in under-construction flats has almost died out completely, because of poor delivery record by real estate companies. Dwarka Expressway is the region with the maximal stagnation and absence of deals since the road infrastructure is yet to be completed.

Prices in completed complexes and ready to move (RTM) flats in Gurgaon, especially in Sohna Road are stagnant with few takers at such high prices. There are no price drops since the investors are holding at current prices and are likely to continue to do so in 2014 as well. Further price escalation in this category is unlikely in 2014 although price drops are also not on the cards. Much of the inventory of ready to occupy flats is already in the hands of the end users or long term investors.

Came True and prices continued to show mild decline in 2014 as well

Prices of under-construction (UC) flats in Gurgaon on the other hand are likely to correct in 2014. In 2013, deals died out, but the prices were stagnant. In 2014, the prolonged stagnation, demand for payment from builders and no visibility of further price appreciation is likely to see liquidation of holdings by investors ready to book the remaining profit and limit outgo as constructions complete. This is therefore an opportunity for end users to strike good deals. The maximal such deals are likely before the central and Haryana assembly elections which are about 5 months and one year away respectively. Potential completion premium, usually estimated at 30% is likely to reduce to a much smaller number of around 5 to 10% and thus the benefits of holding on to the flats has reduced for investors. This is likely to result in dropping resale rates of under-construction property. The reduced completion premium will be more marked in Dwarka Expressway since the road and other infrastructure is lacking and hence end users will not wish to move into suboptimal living conditions. In contrast Golf Course Extension Road might maintain premium due to better surroundings and living conditions.

Came True

Plot market is stagnant in Gurgaon in central and peripheral locations and this is likely to continue in 2014, making it unattractive for short term investors. Because of inventory overhand in apartment segment and escalating construction costs as well as changing trends of end user preference, very few people are constructing builder floors in Gurgaon.

Came True

NOIDA: A similar stagnation of prices to Gurgaon is likely to be seen in NOIDA and Greater NOIDA West, but to a lesser extent since NOIDA has more middle income apartments rather than luxury apartments and hence downside is limited. Since almost all builders have drastically slowed on delivery, and because middle class end users are ready to occupy flats even without infrastructure due to affordability factor, a potentially larger completion premium of 20-30% is likely in NOIDA, quite the reverse to Gurgaon where completion premium is likely to reduce, since most of the property is in the luxury sector. Thus majority of NOIDA investors are likely to hold through for long term and a stagnation in prices is likely throughout 2014 without the anticipated price falls of Gurgaon.

Came True and prices continued to show mild decline in 2014 as well

More peripheral locations in the region like Yamuna Expressway, Greater NOIDA main, Kundli and Faridabad are unlikely to see much activity in 2014. Prices are likely to fall in these regions, but more dramatic will be the absence of resale activity as end users stay away.

Came True

Mumbai: Stagnation in main city is expected. Suburban locations are likely to see reasonable price performance linked to Indian economy coming out of recession. Stagnation in the 5000-10000 psf price range and better performance in the 3500-5000 psf price range is likely.

Came True

Bangalore: Saturation of the Bangalore market in the last two years will lead to stagnant prices but slow and steady off take by end users on the back of numerous launches seen in 2013.

Came True in most locations. Some locations fell

Chennai:If industrial revival takes place in latter half of 2014, then Chennai might see a good number of launches in the affordable housing segment in the periphery. As the infrastructure projects slowly get completed, a better real estate market with new launches as well as redevelopment in plotted segment is possible.

Did not happen

Investing in Property in 2014:

In view of the slowdown, property is a poor sector for investment.

Came True

Long term investors looking to buy property for post retirement self use or for holding periods of over 10 years can enter in select locations, cities and segments and look for bargains. The threads on “distress sale in depressed market” on IREF, located in multiple cities, might be a good place to start for this purpose.

Certain general rules for real estate investment in a slowdown can be kept in mind.

1. In a bear market, one should select property in prime locations and not in peripheral locations, since prime locations will be the first to reverse price direction and will give the most sustained returns once the bull market returns
2. In a bear market, one should invest for the long term. For property, a time frame of 15 years or more is ideal.
3. Short term flipping for quick gains on leverage should not be attempted in bear markets. This technique is reserved for bull markets.
4. The most depressed prices in distress sales will be in luxury property and in plots. These will rise the most when the market turns. Deep pocketed investors with the ability to pick up the distress sale and holding through the uncertainties of the bear market will reap the maximal rewards. Deep pockets and lack of leverage will amplify returns in bear markets – thus bear markets make the rich even richer because they alone can afford to buy and hold. This is in contrast to bull markets where short term holding and leverage amplifies returns and risk takers benefit rather than long term holders.
5. The safest investment for middle class investors in a bear market is already built ready to register flats in the affordable segment in the main central areas of the city with existing infrastructure
Luxury property as a whole is better avoided for the year 2014. This is because prices are already high and it is better to wait for lower prices and for bargains to emerge. As the luxury flats booked by investors slowly get completed, investors will be ready to negotiate with bargain hunters.
Plots are also avoidable because of the existing high prices and the lack of performance in plots in the central areas of Gurgaon even during the bull market of 2010-2012. The higher prices for construction of builder floors on plots has made them expensive and out of reach for many. Buyers are also preferring to live in apartment complexes due to better security and amenities. As such, a changing preference of people over time makes it difficult to extrapolate previous price behavior of plots in the past 50 years. Waiting for better bargains but also actively looking for bargains would be prudent for property investors.

Property in the affordable range of 2500 to 5000 psf range will be the best segment for entry, for both end users and investors, due to limited downside.

All of these were correct advice


The main requirement for a boom in property market is a recovery from the current industrial recession. Until the industrial revival generates more well paying jobs, the real estate market cannot revive. The industrial revival is likely to happen in the next 2 years based on cyclical factors, however the strength of the industrial revival is crucially dependent on the general elections of 2014. A strong decisive pro-industry government will cause a dramatic improvement in the industrial climate and a sustained stock market performance followed by an equally sustained real estate market performance will follow. A fractured mandate will cause a weak revival but consequent turbulence in exchange rates can have unpredictable results on real estate price inflation. High imported inflation, escalation of raw material prices, escalation of capital cost etc can have paradoxical results in the real estate market by making the cost of new construction prohibitive. Existing property which is registered may therefore become more valuable while under construction projects might be abandoned.

The prudent real estate investment is therefore to buy only ready to move ready to register flats in the affordable range in central locations and having good infrastructure – or to wait for the general elections and perhaps the Haryana elections also to get over before making any fresh commitments into property market.


As with equity, the best option is to wait for the general elections to get over.

The best locations for investments in 2014 are:

1. Chennai
2. Bangalore
3. Dwarka in Delhi/NCR
4. RTM property in Thane and other similar locations in Mumbai

The locations to avoid for 2014 are:

1. Dwarka Expressway, Yamuna Expressway, Kundli, Faridabad for location
2. Under-construction property in NOIDA, Gurgaon, Mumbai suburbs, Pune – in all of these locations prefer property which is ready to move and register
3. Plot investments in all locations
4. Land in tier 2 and tier 3 cities – prefer ready to move built up property only

Despite property being in a bear market, it is a good hedge against Rupee depreciation in the long run and hence every person should have some exposure to property. Buying small ready to move in flat (I BHK or smaller if salary is inadequate) based on a small portion (<20 a="" always="" and="" any="" arise="" at="" be="" br="" buying="" can="" does="" done="" emi="" for="" going="" investment="" not="" of="" prudent="" question="" salary="" such="" time.="" timing="" towards="" would="">
All of these were correct advice

ANALYSIS OF LAST YEARS PREDICTIONS

PREDICTIONS IN BLACK

ANALYSIS IN BLUE


Predictions for 2014


I am making this briefer than last year because the main problem is the Indian elections. Everything else depends on that. I have already written on elections.

Broad predictions for USA

Politics: Not much to happen. Budget issues should go through with wrangling

Democrats managed to lose both houses. But budget issues went thru as expected

Economics: Slow improvement throughout 2014 is likely. Jobs will keep growing as the workforce retrains. Corporate investments will continue to be slow and the 2 trillion cash pile with corporate will still not get fully deployed.

Came true

Fed: Likely to pause taper after the bond rate reaches some 3.25 to 3.5 5 and then keep rates at around this level for the remainder of 2014. Short term rates will remain 0. Probably the comfort level for the bond rate is likely to be achieved around 40 billion repurchases per month levels and this should be achieved around April 2014.

They managed to finish tapering after all. Economy did better than expected. I was majorly wrong on bond rates - currently 2.1 to 2.2. About half of my expectation.

Specfic predictions:

Stocks – stagnant. Dow 17000 by end of 2014.

Came true

Bonds – slow fall to bond rates of 3.5% or so, as targeted by Fed

Wrong prediction. Bonds went higher.

Dollar strong. Dollar index 83-85 by end of 2014

Came true

REIT – Expect about 5% annual return from REITS.

Came true

Real estate – stagnant in both old and new areas after recent run up

Came true

Gold – stagnant at about 1150-1250 range.

Came true

For Indian investor: US market can be completely avoided, with the sole exception of US REITS for the sake of 5% dollar denominated returns.

Came partly true. REITS did well but US market returns were very good

Europe Broad Predictions:

Politics: Conservatives and Christian Democrats continue in West Europe.

Came true

Economics: Slow grind without too much out performance by both UK and German companies.

Came true

Steady migration of East Europeans into both these economies should help achieve 3-4% growth for 2014.

Came true for UK.

France less than these two. Italy slow improvement in manufacturing. Spain and other lower country Europe stagnant.

Came true

East Europe good steady growth of 3-4% based on better jobs for their population, increased training levels and also based on remittances from expat workers.

Came partly true. Local East Europe economies didnt do as well as expected


Transatlantic trade block:

This is a major development for 2013 – and presages increased economic co-operation between the North Americans and the Europeans. UK sitting in the middle is likely to be the biggest beneficiary of this future development of a 40-50 trillion GDP economic superpower which is well on the way to being created. This development dwarfs all previous trade zones and will bring great economic benefits. Central to this trade block is the export of energy from USA and the export of engineering technology by Germany. This trade zone is likely to benefit from the upward migration of the Eastern Europeans and the Southern Europeans to higher levels of productivity and will involve increased transnational labour movements in the technology, health care and services sectors. A resurgence of manufacturing in USA is likely to be seen, based increasingly on Mexican workforce moving from 10000 to 25000$ per capita per annum productivity. The world has not yet realized that this massive economic co-operation zone is being created as we speak and that it is this trade zone which will dominate the rest of this century, not China.

The existing Euro zone is destined to break up because of high differences in productivity levels and work cultures – and the transatlantic trade block with individual treaties by each country with major partners is likely to replace the Euro zone. This is a major change in global economics and an early spot of these changing trends can make you a great deal of money. It is not possible for one central bank to set policy for 2 zones with different productivity – that is the main realization which has dawned from the Euro crisis. It is unlikely that Germany and Netherlands will give up their central banking independence for increased trade when the same trade is equally possible over a larger transatlantic trade block with reduced barriers and more advantageous trade agreements.

UK is likely to be the epicenter of the transatlantic trade block and will greatly benefit economically- once again underlining that the English, who kept Bank of England and their own currency are an intellectual super power who have outsmarted the entire world for the past 250 years and continue to dominate even now. Ports and logistics will benefit greatly – UK, Denmark, Norway and Netherlands will all get a piece of this massive cake.

In a way we are harking back to the economics of 1830 to 1870 when Victorian Britannia ruled the waves and the great economic expansion of Europe took place. The basic building blocks of such an economic transition and expansion are on the cards. There has been a 20 year stagnation in productivity of Europeans and Americans. It is likely that better trade, removal of barriers, more manufacturing automation will change this. Germany has already shown the way and rest of Europe and mainland USA is likely to follow. Per capita GDP by 2030 might be 75000 dollars per capita per annum in constant dollars i.e. a 50% increase in productivity of existing population. Add to this a 20% increase in population due to migration of Mexicans and Eastern Europeans over this time period means a 70% increase of total output from 30 trillion to 50 trillion dollars.

If and when Germany leaves Euro, there will be a dramatic 50% response from German stock markets with Dax touching 15000 levels. If UK leaves Euro zone trade restrictions, then again, a dramatic 50% response of FTSE to 12000 levels.

Starting to come true with UK debating on remaining within the Euro. These economic movements likely to play out over next 2 to 3 years

Specific Predictions for 2014

UK: Stocks up. As the block takes off, a spike in FTSE upto 10,000 might occur

Came partly true. FTSE topped out at 7000 only.

UK: Real estate flat. Prices have already run up

Came true

UK: Banks up. Bank of England rates stable for next year with no policy changes for now

UK eased a lot. So wrong prediction. There was insufficient strength from the economy to achieve the prediction.

UK Sterling: likely to strengthen further by 10% over 2014.

Wrong. Sterling strengthened in 2013 but largely static with some weakening against Dollar.

Germany: Stocks flat. Euro zone rates from Draghi likely to be stable.

Stocks were up. Draghi cut

Euro is likely to weaken over 2014 as and when the fissiparous tendencies take hold.

Came true

Transpacific Trade Block

This is the other major trade block which is taking shape, more specifically directed against the Chinese Axis. Likely to be a military-political-economic alliance between Japan, USA, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Malaya, Indonesia, Australia and Vietnam. Apart from the US production of 15 trillion already counted with the trans atlantic alliance, this includes 5 trillion of Japan, 1.5 trillion of Korea, 1.5 trillion of Australia and 1 trillion of Indonesia with the rest small change adding up to another trillion. Assuming growth in Japan GDP to 6 trillion, that means 10-12 trillion of GDP which is one and a half times that of China.

Japan and USA would love to include India within this block but Indians so far are being stupid. Japanese overtures, including the recent visit by the emperor in this regard are however very important. If we get NaMo as PM and republicans in next US elections, then India will be a full partner within this alliance. But if the democrats win and we have a third front in India, then India will get bypassed once again.

These changes will undermine the existing economic blocks in which China has influence – the Japanese investments in Chinese manufacturing, Taiwan investments in mainland China and the South East Asian trade, This trade block is specifically anti Chinese and hence India has much to gain from this alliance.

This is not yet in play but likely to crystallise based on the actions of Modi. A republican win for Jeb Bush would be needed to push this into major action

The Indo Gulf trade block

This is a traditional 4 millennia old trade block – existing from Indus valley civilization, based on sea coast geography - which has been ”blocked” due to the religious divide (Hindu Muslim and Shia Sunni). Once again, if NaMo comes and if Pakistan jettisons the Chinese axis in favour of the Transpacific alliance – then this block can take shape once more after 2 centuries of atrophy under European colonial rule. The shifting sands in Iran are key to this – the cooption of Iran away from China might take place after recent events happening with USA – Iran’s big deal.

Traditionally the Persian Gulf with Oman, UAE/Dubai, Basra/Kuwait, Iranian coast, Karachi and the Kutch ports had been a major trade zone – the biggest in the ancient world. Currently Iran with 500 billion, Soudi with 800 billion, UAE with 400 billion and others with 2-300 billion GDP are mainly oil based economies. Trade related (non oil) GDP of these countries are maybe 500 billion in aggregate, including the contribution of Kutch and Karachi. By 2030 this can quadruple to 2 trillion dollars exclusive of oil. Add to this the transshipment of oil from central asia (Khazakhstan, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan etc) and the potential increases to about 3-4 trillion dollars of new GDP over and above existing GDP. That makes it a great growth area.

More importantly the UAE i.e Dubai and Abu Dhabi coast sitting in the middle of this zone and ready to offer peaceful employment to professionals and industrial workers from everywhere – mainly India especially Malayalees - are sitting on a manufacturing possibility as well. It is possible that the population of UAE might cross 15 million people by 2030 i.e double from current 8 million levels, mainly by expats – and its GDP might cross 1 trillion dollars. Peace in the Persian Gulf would mean a drastic lowering of the risk premium and a tripling of shipping size by 2030.

Essentially, the UAE can provide a zone of peace, law and order and good governance with great infrastructure – and import the manpower from the surrounding countries of South Asia who have high population and good capabilities currently unharnessed due to poor governance – to generate wealth. The model, going on for 30-40 years, has endured well and has reached a take off potential. The recent expulsion of Saudi Expats is likely to give a ready pool for UAE to expand – and the UAE is a Anglo American controlled area – non Sunni Islamist to boot – and is likely to be encouraged to expand at breakneck pace by the Anglo American Alliance. As US moves closer to Iran and reaches equidistance from Saudi – the UAE is likely to be coopted by the Anglo Americans to be a counter weight and demonstrate an alternative model to Saudi Arabia.

Political stability, peace and a major change of Iranian, Pakistani and Afghan mind set is needed for this development. Currently things are hanging in the balance – in all 3 countries.
Of these, the most mature and advanced mindset is in Iran, thanks to its history. The Khomenian regression seems to have largely run its course. Recent deft handling of the nuclear crisis portents well for Iranian integration.

Afghanistan and Pakistan are unbalanced and very poor states. Poor education levels of Afghanistan mean that it can never benefit from the trade – and hence it is likely to be a spoiler.

In Pakistan, a shift in the balance of power away from Punjab and towards Sind and Karachi will be resisted by the Army. But large number of capable professionals can still tilt the balance. My own estimate is that Pakistan will not change or will change after many years – maybe 5 + years and only after an economic crisis.

So the push for this block has to come from Indo Dubai and Indo Iranian Central Asian energy pipeline spearheads – with Anglo American support - which can only happen with good leadership from the like of Modi. Socialists (third front/AAP/ Congress/Communists) are not capable of such vision – India under these have always had poor vision in commerce and foreign policy.

The chances of any of this happening in 2014 are basically nil. But for the first time, the potential has reared its head thanks to the recent Iranian shift – and this fluid situation is worth watching and India’s foreign affairs ministry should try to influence this. Setting up Indo-Dubai Free Trade Zones in Gujarat, Maharashtra and Kerala would be the logical step to access large quantities of capital and also to restart the manpower training of Indians – we badly need to train our workforce.

From India the play is on. Chabahar and the Turkmenistan railway is in play. Iran continues to try to get closer to USA but the Democrats rebuffed them. Again a straight talking republican alone can make these things happen, not a weaselly democrat.

The Shia Sunni cold war is on. The coming of ISIS was unpredictable but has changed the dynamics totally. With Baathists of Syria likely to win, and US tied to Saudi Aramco at the hip, there is no telling how this will play out.

Other global events:

1. Wars: I am downgrading Iran as flashpoint – but renewed Shia Sunni fight for dominance in Syria and efforts by Sunni Pakistan to export nuclear technology to Soudi Arabia continue to be dangerous. Hopefully the UAE’s economic performance will persuade Saudi to look for economic rather than religious dominance, but seems difficult for now. Saudi with 800 billion in output is still the richest and most dominant economy in West Asia. 2014 is a crucial year to see future direction of this great game – as Syria reaches boiling point

There was no export of nuclear technology yet. Likelihood increased though after the Saudi GDP expected contraction to about 700 billion i.e. 15% haircut in the output for the year

2. North Korea: Again downgrading, despite the crazy execution of the uncle. China is actively discouraging adventurism, but still, the young Un is crazy, so unpredictable

Remains as such

3. China Japan – an arms race with Japan/ Taiwan/USA on one side and China on the other for dominance is now inevitable. Since Japanese capital was routed through Taiwan into Chinese manufacturing, there is going to be a lot of rerouting – India can get a piece of the cake but for now, Vietnam (bizarrely) and Indonesia have been more pragmatic in attracting capital

Came true

4. Afghanistan. Very crucial time for this country – the US withdrawal and Karzai leaning towards India – and the usual Indian stupidity in foreign affairs means that a dangerous civil war is looming between Karzai, sections of the Pushtu supporting him and northern alliance on one side and Taliban Pushtu on the other side. Partition of Afghanistan into a Pro-pakistan zone and a Pro-Indian zone is possible – Indian foreign policy should be directed at a favourable partition into Iran borders/Herat/Northern Alliance which is on the side of India but covers the gas bearing and oil pipeline lands – so that a central Asia to Iran gas/oil pipeline can be made which is outside the Taliban Pushto Pakistan Axis. The Rump Pushto/Taliban areas of Afghanistan with majorty of the poor and illiterate Pushtos should be kept away from the pipeline by adequate ethnic cleansing with active American, Iranian and Indian military/diplomatic/special forces CIA action. Iranian ports can be used for the export of both Iranian gas/oil and Central Asian gas/oil. Ultimate long distance aim of India for future Pakistan should be balkanization into the Pushto areas of Rump Afghanistan and NWFP as first area, nuclear defanged Punjab as second area and a new Balochistan/Sind coastal region which should gain partition excluding the Pushto populations of Karachi and Quetta (who go back into the Pushtoonistan regions by ethnic cleansing). The coast of Balochistan/Sind should become port based and integrated into the Indo Gulf trade block. This would also bring the Balochi oil and gas into the trade block. Active resistance from Pakistan and Saudi (1 trillion of GDP together) would need to be broken with CIA help. For now, let us see whether the break in Afghanistan comes along favourable or unfavourable lines – Iran is likely to be more influential in Herat than the stupid Indian blunderings – and Iran is a much better player than India – so easiest prediction is a convulsion in Afghanistan in 2014 with a semi partition – and civil war.

There was no civil war. Thank God.

5. Pakistan: By middle of 2014, the main transpacific alliance would be at logger heads with the Pakistan China Axis – and Pakistan would have to choose sides. I have no clue which side they would choose – but Pakistanis are cleverer than Indians and would play their cards smartly. I hope they would abandon their 60 year alliance with China and choose their equally long 60 year alliance with USA – but I cannot predict. Let us see how the new Army Chief behaves. Nawaz Sharif is anyway total opportunist and will go with the Army.

In the event, the tribal of Khyber and Waziristan being bombed by the Pak Army. Looks like Pakistan hedged its bets for this year. China also pushing Pak on these loonatics - who export terror to Xingiang.

6. Syria: This has gained importance. Whether the Shia or Sunni win is a big deal – because Iraqi Al Qaida is also dependent on continued strife in neighbor Syria. The recent victory of the US-Iran deal will determine future events. If they get closer together, then USA will let the Shia Baathists win against the rebels – this is a favourable event because Iraqi Al Qaida, Wahabi terror and Syrian Sunni rebels are all together and a defeat with return of peace would be in India’s best interests. But very unpredictable. I would predict US victory on the side of the Baathists in 2014.

Came true.

Although ISIS was unpredicted, ultimately the US bombed the ISIS which was on the side of the Baathists only. Because of the bizarre madness of ISIS, it has ensured defeat for the Sunnis and victory for the Shia, much against the wishes of USA.


7. Egypt. The jasmine revolution has failed in Egypt. Unlike in India where AAP has found favour, in Egypt every event has been unfavourable. A slow withering of the Muslim brotherhood is the favourable event for India – but unfortunately the reverse seems to be happening. Egyptians are quite intelligent and a democratic and prosperous Egypt (which in the past was anti middle class like India and forced emigration of Egyptian expats like Indians) – and a resurgence of industry, services and manufacturing in Egypt would be in the best interests of India and the world. But my prediction for Egypt is turmoil in 2014.

Came true
. Muslim brotherhood is out.

8. South America – the bursting of the commodity bubble has caused a return of inflation and poor economic performance – along with resurgence of leftists. The alliance with China is saving a lot of these countries from economic ruin – and is bad news for India and the Anti Chinese alliance. My prediction for 2014 is increased leftist activity, persistent inflation and turbulence in the region.

Came true

Specific predictions for the world events – for 2014

1. Transatlantic alliance: Low key for now. German decisions on Euro Zone unlikely in 2014. No progress expected

Came true

2. Transpacific alliance: Likely to be very active.

Was less active than I expected

3. Military activity in Pacific: China has one aircraft carrier and second is under construction. Japan has 1+1. USA has 10+3. China and Japan are are likely to commission one more each. USA is likely to reduce carrier groups in Gulf and shift to Chinese region. Japan and India are likely to commission many submarines – the next cold war is likely to be sea based, carrier based, submarine based, cruise missile based and drone based. Massive Japanese investment into drone technology is likely. There is already news chatter in this regard after the Senkaku islands.

Came true

4. Military activity in Korea: Increased threat perception in North Korea due to the drone technology of Japan can cause a war – 5% chance.

Did not come true

5. Military activity in Gulf: Unlikely. USA and Iran likely to stay quiet while the small time activities of Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan sort themselves out. US likely to see which way Pakistan goes – USA or china.

Came true

6. Syria – slow death of the rebels is likely

Coming true despite spectacular gains of ISIS. By edging out the moderates, ISIS has ensured its own demise

7. Iraq – slow death of the Al Qaida is likely

Wrong - ISIS took over most of the country. Goo play by the Shias - the ISIS is so extreme, it ensures its own slow death. MEanwhile they have made like hell for the Sunnis and the Kurds - which is to the advantage of the Shias.

8. Iran – likely to get closer to USA

Iran tried but the US trying to balance with Saudi

9. Afghanistan – increased Al Qaida activity as USA exits – likely to force a rethink in USA on exiting. Postponement of exit is likely in case Iran gets closer to USA – so I predict that US will not withdraw completely from Afghanistan and a new political grouping with increased Iranian influence will emerge in 2014.

Did not happen. US did withdraw more than expected. New govt did come but not pro Iranian.

10. Egypt – Al Qaida/muslim brotherhood activity likely to increase.

Wrong - brotherhood finished off

Country wise economic broad and specific predictions.

China: Good GDP growth. Military expenditure and employment will grow – being unproductive, it will crowd out investment lead growth, but cause good employment generation and local consumption. Reduced Japanese and US investments likely – despite that local investments are likely to propel economic growth based on productivity increases.

Came true

Specific: Shanghai Index 2500 by year. Currency stable. Bond rates stable. Investment in Chinese stock market recommended – Mirae China Advantage Fund

Came true. If you had invested in China, 40% return instead of my predicted 20%.

Nikkei – 18000 based on pick up of activity and near shoring of manufacturing in Japan.

Came true

Prefer China over Japan for investment

Came true

Australia –flat

Gulf – 10% growth in stocks and RE. Dubai real estate for HNI recommended over London.

Wrong. Economies in free fall, stocks and real estate down a lot


Brazil – flat. South American Funds skewed towards Mexico might perform better than Brazil focused funds.

Came true

India:

Politics: BJP win 100%.

Came true

Modi as PM 80%.

Came true

Non Modi PM (Advani/Chauhan 20%).

AAP 20 seats.

Wrong

Congress wipe out in almost all states including Karnataka.

Wrong

Lalu resurgent

Wrong

, Nitish wipeout,

Came true

Navin Patnaik steady,

Came true

Mulayam wipe out,

Came true

Maya poorer performance than expected,

Came true

Amma dominant,

Came true

Mamta steady.

Came true

Economics: 4.5 % growth

Came true with upward bias.

RBI rates: Flat for now and flat for later as well – current rates are a comfort zone.

Came true

Rupee: Flat for now, slow and steady depreciation to about 64-65 after the taper reached 40 billion repurchases. Expected nadir in May

Came true

Stock: 25000 by April 2014. One can book profit since both nadir of taper and elections are coinciding – sit on liquid funds for April-May – wait for fall and re-enter regardless of who wins in elections. If Modi wins big, 30000 by year end, If confusion, then still stocks likely to end 2014 at 25000 at least

Came true

Sectors: Secular upside in cyclical as well as defensives including FMCG – basically broad based. Go with diversified mutual funds.

Came true

Bond rates: Steady at 8.75% long term rates throughout 2014.

Bond rates came down without much RBI activity

Gold: Steady/mild uptrend to 30-31000 based on Rupee depreciation (dollar appreciation against gold will cancel out most of the gains)

Gold much lower than expected

Real Estate: Flat to downtrend of 10-15%.

Came true

RTM and ready made flats will have stagnant prices.

They also fell

Completion premium downgraded to 10% upside for UC (instead of usual 30% premium).

Came true

Without completion, 10% fall in prices for delayed flats by 2014

Came true

Best performace in real estate: Chennai and Bangalore

Came true

Worst performance in real estate: Yamuna Expressway, Dwarka Expressway, Mumbai main, Tier 2 and Tier 3 towns

Came true

Stagnant prices: Delhi, Mumbai Suburbs, Pune, NOIDA, Gurgaon.

They also fell a lot except Pune and Mumbai Suburbs

Agriculture: Flat prices for grains based on govt purchase. Vegetables stable with increased supply. Mild palmolein price inflation due to Rupee weakness – feeding FMCG price rise and slightly lower realizations

Came true

Chances of War: Pakistan and China mostly on wait and watch mode. China will increase pressure on borders if Iran and Pakistan both shift to USA – especially if NaMo is PM, since the frenzy from media will weaken India. NaMo will be forced to respond. Mature response from Namo is needed for market stability – but I expect him to rise to the occasion.

Came true

Summary of Predictions by end 2014

Dow 17000 Came true

US Bond rate 3.5% Wrong

Gold in dollars 1150-1250 with 1150 in May 2014 Came true

US REIT – 5 % returns Came true

US Real Estate – Stagnant. Came true

Brent - 110 MAJOR WRONG

Nymex - 100 MAJOR WRONG

FTSE – 10000 MAJOR WRONG

London Real Estate – Stagnant to mild 2-5% fall Came true

Dubai Real Estate – Up 10% MAJOR WRONG

Cac - 4500 Came true

Dax - 10000 Came true

Shanghai Composite - 2500 Came true but went much further up

Nikkei - 20000 Came true but did not rise as much as expected

Latin America – Down 10% Came true

Sense-x: 30,000 Came true

Gold in Rupees: 31000 Was much lower

Indian Bond Rate: 8.75% MAJOR WRONG

Indian RE: No returns Came true




ASSET RECOMMENDATIONS


Decadal

Asset of the decade: Stocks (the decade starting 2014-2024)

Asset to avoid for the decade: Gold

Yearly

Asset of the year 2014: Stocks. FD/FMP/bonds equally good. Correct recommendation

Asset to avoid for 2014: Gold and Real estate Correct recommendation

Fresh allocations for 2014: 60% stocks, 30% FMP/tax free bonds, 10% dollar denominatedCorrect recommendation

Balancing of existing allocations for 2014:

Stocks increase to 45% Correct recommendation

Bonds/Debt increase to 30% Correct recommendation

Real estate decrease/no further additions until it reduces to 20% Correct recommendation

Gold 0% Correct recommendation

Dollar denominated (non gold) 5% Correct recommendation


All in all, I think most of the final recommendations were correct

This happened despite majorly missing the oil fall and the slow fall in both US 10 year and Indian 10 year rates to very low levels. DEspite that, a majority of the events were predictable including the elections and the Syrian problems.

Let me now think about the new year predictions

Wednesday, July 23, 2014

Predictions for 2014 (Made in Jan)

Forgot to post my predictions here. Reproduced from IREF


Predictions for 2014

I am making this briefer than last year because the main problem is the Indian elections. Everything else depends on that. I have already written on elections.

Broad predictions for USA[/U][/B] [B] Politics:[/B] Not much to happen. Budget issues should go through with wrangling [B]Economics:[/B] Slow improvement throughout 2014 is likely. Jobs will keep growing as the workforce retrains. Corporate investments will continue to be slow and the 2 trillion cash pile with corporate will still not get fully deployed. [B]Fed: [/B]Likely to pause taper after the bond rate reaches some 3.25 to 3.5 5 and then keep rates at around this level for the remainder of 2014. Short term rates will remain 0. Probably the comfort level for the bond rate is likely to be achieved around 40 billion repurchases per month levels and this should be achieved around April 2014. [B][U]Specfic predictions:[/U][/B] Stocks – stagnant. Dow 17000 by end of 2014. Bonds – slow fall to bond rates of 3.5% or so, as targeted by Fed Dollar strong. Dollar index 83-85 by end of 2014 REIT – Expect about 5% annual return from REITS. Real estate – stagnant in both old and new areas after recent run up Gold – stagnant at about 1150-1250 range. For Indian investor: US market can be completely avoided, with the sole exception of US REITS for the sake of 5% dollar denominated returns. [B][U]Europe Broad Predictions:[/U][/B] [B]Politics:[/B] Conservatives and Christian Democrats continue in West Europe. [B]Economics:[/B] Slow grind without too much out performance by both UK and German companies. Steady migration of East Europeans into both these economies should help achieve 3-4% growth for 2014. France less than these two. Italy slow improvement in manufacturing. Spain and other lower country Europe stagnant. East Europe good steady growth of 3-4% based on better jobs for their population, increased training levels and also based on remittances from expat workers. [B][U]Transatlantic trade block:[/U][/B] This is a major development for 2013 – and presages increased economic co-operation between the North Americans and the Europeans. UK sitting in the middle is likely to be the biggest beneficiary of this future development of a 40-50 trillion GDP economic superpower which is well on the way to being created. This development dwarfs all previous trade zones and will bring great economic benefits. Central to this trade block is the export of energy from USA and the export of engineering technology by Germany. This trade zone is likely to benefit from the upward migration of the Eastern Europeans and the Southern Europeans to higher levels of productivity and will involve increased transnational labour movements in the technology, health care and services sectors. A resurgence of manufacturing in USA is likely to be seen, based increasingly on Mexican workforce moving from 10000 to 25000$ per capita per annum productivity. The world has not yet realized that this massive economic co-operation zone is being created as we speak and that it is this trade zone which will dominate the rest of this century, not China. The existing Euro zone is destined to break up because of high differences in productivity levels and work cultures – and the transatlantic trade block with individual treaties by each country with major partners is likely to replace the Euro zone. This is a major change in global economics and an early spot of these changing trends can make you a great deal of money. It is not possible for one central bank to set policy for 2 zones with different productivity – that is the main realization which has dawned from the Euro crisis. It is unlikely that Germany and Netherlands will give up their central banking independence for increased trade when the same trade is equally possible over a larger transatlantic trade block with reduced barriers and more advantageous trade agreements. UK is likely to be the epicenter of the transatlantic trade block and will greatly benefit economically- once again underlining that the English, who kept Bank of England and their own currency are an intellectual super power who have outsmarted the entire world for the past 250 years and continue to dominate even now. Ports and logistics will benefit greatly – UK, Denmark, Norway and Netherlands will all get a piece of this massive cake. In a way we are harking back to the economics of 1830 to 1870 when Victorian Britannia ruled the waves and the great economic expansion of Europe took place. The basic building blocks of such an economic transition and expansion are on the cards. There has been a 20 year stagnation in productivity of Europeans and Americans. It is likely that better trade, removal of barriers, more manufacturing automation will change this. Germany has already shown the way and rest of Europe and mainland USA is likely to follow. Per capita GDP by 2030 might be 75000 dollars per capita per annum in constant dollars i.e. a 50% increase in productivity of existing population. Add to this a 20% increase in population due to migration of Mexicans and Eastern Europeans over this time period means a 70% increase of total output from 30 trillion to 50 trillion dollars. If and when Germany leaves Euro, there will be a dramatic 50% response from German stock markets with Dax touching 15000 levels. If UK leaves Euro zone trade restrictions, then again, a dramatic 50% response of FTSE to 12000 levels. [B][U]Specific Predictions for 2014[/U][/B] UK: Stocks up. As the block takes off, a spike in FTSE upto 10,000 might occur UK: Real estate flat. Prices have already run up UK: Banks up. Bank of England rates stable for next year with no policy changes for now UK Sterling: likely to strengthen further by 10% over 2014. Germany: Stocks flat. Euro zone rates from Draghi likely to be stable. Euro is likely to weaken over 2014 as and when the fissiparous tendencies take hold. [B][U]Transpacific Trade Block[/U][/B] This is the other major trade block which is taking shape, more specifically directed against the Chinese Axis. Likely to be a military-political-economic alliance between Japan, USA, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Malaya, Indonesia, Australia and Vietnam. Apart from the US production of 15 trillion already counted with the trans atlantic alliance, this includes 5 trillion of Japan, 1.5 trillion of Korea, 1.5 trillion of Australia and 1 trillion of Indonesia with the rest small change adding up to another trillion. Assuming growth in Japan GDP to 6 trillion, that means 10-12 trillion of GDP which is one and a half times that of China. Japan and USA would love to include India within this block but Indians so far are being stupid. Japanese overtures, including the recent visit by the emperor in this regard are however very important. If we get NaMo as PM and republicans in next US elections, then India will be a full partner within this alliance. But if the democrats win and we have a third front in India, then India will get bypassed once again. These changes will undermine the existing economic blocks in which China has influence – the Japanese investments in Chinese manufacturing, Taiwan investments in mainland China and the South East Asian trade, This trade block is specifically anti Chinese and hence India has much to gain from this alliance. [B][U]The Indo Gulf trade block[/U][/B] This is a traditional 4 millennia old trade block – existing from Indus valley civilization, based on sea coast geography - which has been ”blocked” due to the religious divide (Hindu Muslim and Shia Sunni). Once again, if NaMo comes and if Pakistan jettisons the Chinese axis in favour of the Transpacific alliance – then this block can take shape once more after 2 centuries of atrophy under European colonial rule. The shifting sands in Iran are key to this – the cooption of Iran away from China might take place after recent events happening with USA – Iran’s big deal. Traditionally the Persian Gulf with Oman, UAE/Dubai, Basra/Kuwait, Iranian coast, Karachi and the Kutch ports had been a major trade zone – the biggest in the ancient world. Currently Iran with 500 billion, Soudi with 800 billion, UAE with 400 billion and others with 2-300 billion GDP are mainly oil based economies. Trade related (non oil) GDP of these countries are maybe 500 billion in aggregate, including the contribution of Kutch and Karachi. By 2030 this can quadruple to 2 trillion dollars exclusive of oil. Add to this the transshipment of oil from central asia (Khazakhstan, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan etc) and the potential increases to about 3-4 trillion dollars of new GDP over and above existing GDP. That makes it a great growth area. More importantly the UAE i.e Dubai and Abu Dhabi coast sitting in the middle of this zone and ready to offer peaceful employment to professionals and industrial workers from everywhere – mainly India especially Malayalees - are sitting on a manufacturing possibility as well. It is possible that the population of UAE might cross 15 million people by 2030 i.e double from current 8 million levels, mainly by expats – and its GDP might cross 1 trillion dollars. Peace in the Persian Gulf would mean a drastic lowering of the risk premium and a tripling of shipping size by 2030. Essentially, the UAE can provide a zone of peace, law and order and good governance with great infrastructure – and import the manpower from the surrounding countries of South Asia who have high population and good capabilities currently unharnessed due to poor governance – to generate wealth. The model, going on for 30-40 years, has endured well and has reached a take off potential. The recent expulsion of Saudi Expats is likely to give a ready pool for UAE to expand – and the UAE is a Anglo American controlled area – non Sunni Islamist to boot – and is likely to be encouraged to expand at breakneck pace by the Anglo American Alliance. As US moves closer to Iran and reaches equidistance from Saudi – the UAE is likely to be coopted by the Anglo Americans to be a counter weight and demonstrate an alternative model to Saudi Arabia. Political stability, peace and a major change of Iranian, Pakistani and Afghan mind set is needed for this development. Currently things are hanging in the balance – in all 3 countries. Of these, the most mature and advanced mindset is in Iran, thanks to its history. The Khomenian regression seems to have largely run its course. Recent deft handling of the nuclear crisis portents well for Iranian integration. Afghanistan and Pakistan are unbalanced and very poor states. Poor education levels of Afghanistan mean that it can never benefit from the trade – and hence it is likely to be a spoiler. In Pakistan, a shift in the balance of power away from Punjab and towards Sind and Karachi will be resisted by the Army. But large number of capable professionals can still tilt the balance. My own estimate is that Pakistan will not change or will change after many years – maybe 5 + years and only after an economic crisis. So the push for this block has to come from Indo Dubai and Indo Iranian Central Asian energy pipeline spearheads – with Anglo American support - which can only happen with good leadership from the like of Modi. Socialists (third front/AAP/ Congress/Communists) are not capable of such vision – India under these have always had poor vision in commerce and foreign policy. The chances of any of this happening in 2014 are basically nil. But for the first time, the potential has reared its head thanks to the recent Iranian shift – and this fluid situation is worth watching and India’s foreign affairs ministry should try to influence this. Setting up Indo-Dubai Free Trade Zones in Gujarat, Maharashtra and Kerala would be the logical step to access large quantities of capital and also to restart the manpower training of Indians – we badly need to train our workforce. [B][U]Other global events:[/U][/B] 1. [B]Wars[/B]: I am downgrading Iran as flashpoint – but renewed Shia Sunni fight for dominance in Syria and efforts by Sunni Pakistan to export nuclear technology to Soudi Arabia continue to be dangerous. Hopefully the UAE’s economic performance will persuade Saudi to look for economic rather than religious dominance, but seems difficult for now. Saudi with 800 billion in output is still the richest and most dominant economy in West Asia. 2014 is a crucial year to see future direction of this great game – as Syria reaches boiling point 2. [B]North Korea:[/B] Again downgrading, despite the crazy execution of the uncle. China is actively discouraging adventurism, but still, the young Un is crazy, so unpredictable 3. [B]China Japan [/B]– an arms race with Japan/ Taiwan/USA on one side and China on the other for dominance is now inevitable. Since Japanese capital was routed through Taiwan into Chinese manufacturing, there is going to be a lot of rerouting – India can get a piece of the cake but for now, Vietnam (bizarrely) and Indonesia have been more pragmatic in attracting capital 4. [B]Afghanistan.[/B] Very crucial time for this country – the US withdrawal and Karzai leaning towards India – and the usual Indian stupidity in foreign affairs means that a dangerous civil war is looming between Karzai, sections of the Pushtu supporting him and northern alliance on one side and Taliban Pushtu on the other side. Partition of Afghanistan into a Pro-pakistan zone and a Pro-Indian zone is possible – Indian foreign policy should be directed at a favourable partition into Iran borders/Herat/Northern Alliance which is on the side of India but covers the gas bearing and oil pipeline lands – so that a central Asia to Iran gas/oil pipeline can be made which is outside the Taliban Pushto Pakistan Axis. The Rump Pushto/Taliban areas of Afghanistan with majorty of the poor and illiterate Pushtos should be kept away from the pipeline by adequate ethnic cleansing with active American, Iranian and Indian military/diplomatic/special forces CIA action. Iranian ports can be used for the export of both Iranian gas/oil and Central Asian gas/oil. Ultimate long distance aim of India for future Pakistan should be balkanization into the Pushto areas of Rump Afghanistan and NWFP as first area, nuclear defanged Punjab as second area and a new Balochistan/Sind coastal region which should gain partition excluding the Pushto populations of Karachi and Quetta (who go back into the Pushtoonistan regions by ethnic cleansing). The coast of Balochistan/Sind should become port based and integrated into the Indo Gulf trade block. This would also bring the Balochi oil and gas into the trade block. Active resistance from Pakistan and Saudi (1 trillion of GDP together) would need to be broken with CIA help. For now, let us see whether the break in Afghanistan comes along favourable or unfavourable lines – Iran is likely to be more influential in Herat than the stupid Indian blunderings – and Iran is a much better player than India – so easiest prediction is a convulsion in Afghanistan in 2014 with a semi partition – and civil war. 5. [B]Pakistan:[/B] By middle of 2014, the main transpacific alliance would be at logger heads with the Pakistan China Axis – and Pakistan would have to choose sides. I have no clue which side they would choose – but Pakistanis are cleverer than Indians and would play their cards smartly. I hope they would abandon their 60 year alliance with China and choose their equally long 60 year alliance with USA – but I cannot predict. Let us see how the new Army Chief behaves. Nawaz Sharif is anyway total opportunist and will go with the Army. 6. [B]Syria:[/B] This has gained importance. Whether the Shia or Sunni win is a big deal – because Iraqi Al Qaida is also dependent on continued strife in neighbor Syria. The recent victory of the US-Iran deal will determine future events. If they get closer together, then USA will let the Shia Baathists win against the rebels – this is a favourable event because Iraqi Al Qaida, Wahabi terror and Syrian Sunni rebels are all together and a defeat with return of peace would be in India’s best interests. But very unpredictable. I would predict US victory on the side of the Baathists in 2014. 7. [B]Egypt[/B]. The jasmine revolution has failed in Egypt. Unlike in India where AAP has found favour, in Egypt every event has been unfavourable. A slow withering of the Muslim brotherhood is the favourable event for India – but unfortunately the reverse seems to be happening. Egyptians are quite intelligent and a democratic and prosperous Egypt (which in the past was anti middle class like India and forced emigration of Egyptian expats like Indians) – and a resurgence of industry, services and manufacturing in Egypt would be in the best interests of India and the world. But my prediction for Egypt is turmoil in 2014. 8. [B]South America[/B] – the bursting of the commodity bubble has caused a return of inflation and poor economic performance – along with resurgence of leftists. The alliance with China is saving a lot of these countries from economic ruin – and is bad news for India and the Anti Chinese alliance. My prediction for 2014 is increased leftist activity, persistent inflation and turbulence in the region. [B][U]Specific predictions for the world events – for 2014[/U][/B] 1. [B]Transatlantic alliance:[/B] Low key for now. German decisions on Euro Zone unlikely in 2014. No progress expected 2. [B]Transpacific alliance:[/B] Likely to be very active. 3. [B]Military activity in Pacific:[/B] China has one aircraft carrier and second is under construction. Japan has 1+1. USA has 10+3. China and Japan are are likely to commission one more each. USA is likely to reduce carrier groups in Gulf and shift to Chinese region. Japan and India are likely to commission many submarines – the next cold war is likely to be sea based, carrier based, submarine based, cruise missile based and drone based. Massive Japanese investment into drone technology is likely. There is already news chatter in this regard after the Senkaku islands. 4. [B]Military activity in Korea:[/B] Increased threat perception in North Korea due to the drone technology of Japan can cause a war – 5% chance. 5. [B]Military activity in Gulf:[/B] Unlikely. USA and Iran likely to stay quiet while the small time activities of Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan sort themselves out. US likely to see which way Pakistan goes – USA or china. 6. [B]Syria [/B]– slow death of the rebels is likely 7. [B]Iraq[/B] – slow death of the Al Qaida is likely 8. [B]Iran[/B] – likely to get closer to USA 9. [B]Afghanistan [/B]– increased Al Qaida activity as USA exits – likely to force a rethink in USA on exiting. Postponement of exit is likely in case Iran gets closer to USA – so I predict that US will not withdraw completely from Afghanistan and a new political grouping with increased Iranian influence will emerge in 2014. 10.[B] Egypt[/B] – Al Qaida/muslim brotherhood activity likely to increase. [B][U]Country wise economic broad and specific predictions.[/U][/B] [B]China:[/B] Good GDP growth. Military expenditure and employment will grow – being unproductive, it will crowd out investment lead growth, but cause good employment generation and local consumption. Reduced Japanese and US investments likely – despite that local investments are likely to propel economic growth based on productivity increases. Specific: Shanghai Index 2500 by year. Currency stable. Bond rates stable. Investment in Chinese stock market recommended – Mirae China Advantage Fund [B]Nikkei [/B]– 18000 based on pick up of activity and near shoring of manufacturing in Japan. Prefer China over Japan for investment [B]Australia [/B]–flat [B]Gulf [/B]– 10% growth in stocks and RE. Dubai real estate for HNI recommended over London. [B]Brazil[/B] – flat. South American Funds skewed towards Mexico might perform better than Brazil focused funds. [B][U]India:[/U][/B] [B]Politics:[/B] BJP win 100%. Modi as PM 80%. Non Modi PM (Advani/Chauhan 20%). AAP 20 seats. Congress wipe out in almost all states including Karnataka. Lalu resurgent, Nitish wipeout, Navin Patnaik steady, Mulayam wipe out, Maya poorer performance than expected, Amma dominant, Mamta steady. [B][COLOR="Red"]For detailed predictions: [/COLOR][/B] [url]http://www.indianrealestateforum.com/off-topic-forum/t-indian-political-outlook-2014-a-71572.html[/url] [B][U] Economics:[/U][/B] 4.5 % growth [B]RBI rates:[/B] Flat for now and flat for later as well – current rates are a comfort zone. [B]Rupee:[/B] Flat for now, slow and steady depreciation to about 64-65 after the taper reached 40 billion repurchases. Expected nadir in May [B]Stock: [/B]25000 by April 2014. One can book profit since both nadir of taper and elections are coinciding – sit on liquid funds for April-May – wait for fall and re-enter regardless of who wins in elections. If Modi wins big, 30000 by year end, If confusion, then still stocks likely to end 2014 at 25000 at least [B]Sectors:[/B] Secular upside in cyclical as well as defensives including FMCG – basically broad based. Go with diversified mutual funds. [B]Bond rates:[/B] Steady at 8.75% long term rates throughout 2014. [B]Gold:[/B] Steady/mild uptrend to 30-31000 based on Rupee depreciation (dollar appreciation against gold will cancel out most of the gains) [B]Real Estate:[/B] Flat to downtrend of 10-15%. RTM and ready made flats will have stagnant prices. Completion premium downgraded to 10% upside for UC (instead of usual 30% premium). Without completion, 10% fall in prices for delayed flats by 2014 [B]Best performace in real estate:[/B] Chennai and Bangalore [B]Worst performance in real estate:[/B] Yamuna Expressway, Dwarka Expressway, Mumbai main, Tier 2 and Tier 3 towns [B]Stagnant prices:[/B] Delhi, Mumbai Suburbs, Pune, NOIDA, Gurgaon. [B]Agriculture: [/B]Flat prices for grains based on govt purchase. Vegetables stable with increased supply. Mild palmolein price inflation due to Rupee weakness – feeding FMCG price rise and slightly lower realizations [B]Chances of War:[/B] Pakistan and China mostly on wait and watch mode. China will increase pressure on borders if Iran and Pakistan both shift to USA – especially if NaMo is PM, since the frenzy from media will weaken India. NaMo will be forced to respond. Mature response from Namo is needed for market stability – but I expect him to rise to the occasion. [B][U]Summary of Predictions by end 2014[/U][/B] Dow 17000 US Bond rate 3.5% Gold in dollars 1150-1250 with 1150 in May 2014 US REIT – 5 % returns US Real Estate – Stagnant. Brent - 110 Nymex - 100 FTSE – 10000 London Real Estate – Stagnant to mild 2-5% fall Dubai Real Estate – Up 10% Cac - 4500 Dax - 10000 Shanghai Composite - 2500 Nikkei - 20000 Latin America – Down 10% Sense-x: 30,000 Gold in Rupees: 31000 Indian Bond Rate: 8.75% Indian RE: No returns [B][U]ASSET RECOMMENDATIONS[/U][/B] [B][U]Decadal[/U][/B] Asset of the decade: Stocks (the decade starting 2014-2024) Asset to avoid for the decade: Gold [B][U]Yearly[/U][/B] Asset of the year 2014: Stocks. FD/FMP/bonds equally good. Asset to avoid for 2014: Gold and Real estate Fresh allocations for 2014: 60% stocks, 30% FMP/tax free bonds, 10% dollar denominated [B]Balancing of existing allocations for 2014:[/B] Stocks increase to 45% Bonds/Debt increase to 30% Real estate decrease/no further additions until it reduces to 20% Gold 0% Dollar denominated (non gold) 5%[/JUSTIFY]

Why Rupee is not strengthening despite FII inflow

1. RBI has been soaking up the inflow by building reserves. It is sterilising the Rupee it is releasing at fairly high interest rates - so net effect is that the Rupee is strengthened by the high rates but the supply demand mismatch is not causing Rupee appreciation either because RBI is providing the demand to make up for any slack in demand. So Rupee is stable.

Since rates are high the injection of Rupee in our markets is not stoking inflation

Rajen is proving more than adept. Modi + Jaitly + Rajan is a winning combo.

2. Dollar has been strengthening - and this is happening despite the low US bond yields of 2.48% which indicates a flight to safety due to low Euro and Japanese yields and economic performance. So net effect is to keep Rupee stable

3. Imports are picking up. It is an early indicator of future growth in our economy. But imports increase demand for dollar and keep Dollar strong viv-a-vis Rupee

4. All of these are likely to keep Rupee stable. Otherwise the natural tendency of Rupee should be to depreciate given our inflation difference. So inflows would cause volatile appreciation followed by volatile depreciation at the first sign of stopping.

5. Japan and China keep their currency weak by building reserves. RBI is doing the same thing. I think RBI would be happy to average a 2-3% depreciation of Rupee per annum but in a slow and steady way rather than in sudden uncontrolled jerks like Subbarao allowed

Friday, March 28, 2014

After Two Viewings of Queen

I saw Queen in Bangalore with my niece because she wanted to see it. I hadnt read anything about it and generally dont see Hindi movies - and the punjabi wedding scene start was very very ominous - I wondered what I had committed 2.5 hours to?

Within 20 minutes I was loving it and it kept getting better and better. One of the best Hindi movies I have ever seen.

But last weekend I saw the movie again with my wife and kids - and being forwarned about everything that was to come - it was still enjoyable enough after just 15 days of first viewing. But this time, I was able to more critically evaluate the film-makers craft this time and was most impressed.

http://variety.com/2014/film/reviews/film-review-queen-1201143643/

I read this review of Queen by a western reviewer (link above) and realised - they simply cannot get this movie. This is a movie by Indians for Indians. It is just not meant for anyone else. This is a movie which portrays Indians as the majority really are - just exaggerated and compressed into a short movie. Yes, the minority of families who were "Westernised" in the 70s and 80s may have pretensions of being better but even amongst them, a majority will find that at least some part of the movie applies to them.

The majority of Indian boys and girls do meet under parental supervision for the first time - and progresses exactly like this - clunky and low brow. Those with higher pretensions might turn up their noses at them - but they are mostly nerds who dont meet or date anyone at all - just watch "How I Met Your Mother" and pretend they are highly sophisticated and would do far better if they ever meet a girl - which they dont. A small jet set might not be this way - but they are miniscule.

Every family who has traveled abroad would relate to having "lug" the luggage upstairs, being hesitant and over thinking simple things like crossing the road, taking a train, figuring out metro or train routes, using a map, hailing a cab without seeing where the line is 

Saturday, March 22, 2014

Analysis of last years predictions- World and India

I had posted my analysis of my 2013 Jan predictions in end of December 2013 here:

But I forgot to post it on my blog, so doing so now: The parts in black are 2012 predictions for 2013, the parts in red are the analysis at the end of the year

Analysis of last years predictions - world long term


I guess it is time to look at what I said last year and what actually happened. My observations are in blue:

WORLD AND USA.

Science. 

Current world view seems set to be static for the foreseeable future. Lack of significant progress in solving the unsolved mysteries of the cosmic expansion and dark matter mean the current views, now 30 years old, will continue until we achieve some breakthrough. No progress in the grand unified theory or quantum mechanics is likely and one can safely predict this status to continue till 2050 at least. So its a dead end in our lifetimes. Discovery of the Higgs Boson recently means a confirmation of 50 year old thinking process and a certain death for alternative theories for a decade or more. The reopening of the large hadron collider is more likely to emphasise the mysteries of universe expansion and dark matter rather than solve it.

Unless chance events throw up another Einstein. Unlikely because in the early 20th century, there were 100s of brilliant minds making a 100s of new discoveries of which Einstein was the best. Not so todays – nothing like the same situation.Space exploration is unlikely to advance at even the current pace as the money available for it keeps on reducing. Western economies are unable to raise funds for this for a decade.

The scientific world seems to agree with this - except that new mathematical support for sudden mass increase has injected another unknown dimension into it. We are still far far away from a breakthrough


Although these are predictions where I would prefer to be proved wrong!

How to profit from it – project past events into the future. History will repeat itself

Maintain this

Technology.

The breakneck race of better and better computing devices and more and more integrated networks is likely to continue and be unpredictable even 3 years hence. Still, some points are noticeable.

1. We are still doing in 2012 what we were doing in 1998, just better and faster and more portable. And more people are doing it. The current internet generation is just a logical progression from the  com boom.

2. Devices will continue into smaller and more portable  computers and tablets with ever greater processing speeds with ever decreasing power requirements prolonging battery life.

3. Cloud computing and apps will progress further.

Where I see us in 2020.

1. Mobiles. S3/note 2 level will be the entry level  phone and will be used by everybody. Prices will drop to where even the poorest can afford it or provided by govt. Likely to serve as money and identity card with biometric tagging of the device to the user.

Proved true within the year

2. 4 tablet segments of 4 inch, 5.5 inch, 7-8 inch and 10 inch will be standard and used by every one including  a-pple (i.e I am a 5.5 inch  product from a-pple)

Coming true soon !

3. The difference between  a-pple and competitors will drop. Even the cheapest tablet will be better than ipad 4 and everyone will have them

4. Desktops will vanish even more and become extinct.

5. Laptops will change into tablet/ultrabook combo – thinner, lighter and dual purpose.

How to profit from it. Sell a-pple.

 moved down a lot and languished for most of the year but recently up again - higher that the beginning of the year - some 5% up from the start, but had gone up 10% over beginning of the year - I think it was the right call despite that.

Buy  g-00gle and Microsoft stock.

Google and Microsoft up 40% or so from beginning of the year. So right call again 

Because  a-pple will no longer be able to charge a premium and incremental software improvements which differentiate  from the crowd are disappearing. Microsoft has got W8 right and should benefit from future developments in ultrabook tablet combos.

Disruptive technologies

1. Wearable computing and virtual reality are now having sufficient miniaturization to actually take off. Just like Microsoft in 2002 could not do anything with tablets because of lack of technology but  in 2009 could, virtual reality now is in take off mode. In 1998 and recently devices have been a failure because the headgear has been too big and clunky. The google efforts in retinal projection devices will become big in 2013 and beyond with wearable devices with massive computing power, fibreoptic displays using small spectacle sized headsets where pupil sized projection outputs centered using laser positioning and using eyeball movement in addition to head movement will capture a more realistic rendering of the virtual world. It is now possible to have immersive reality experiences and good quality reality rendering to make VR a meaningful technology for gaming and virtual interaction. By 2015 to 2018 I see it being a big hit and optical cabling will be a big part of it, making it expensive. Virtual reality theatres with 3D immersive experience will usher in a new movie experience by 2018. All other movie theatres will vanish. What will start for the rich by 2020 will become a mass phenomenon by 2030.

VR games have made a come back within one year itself. Right call.

2. Foldable screens and projection technology will do to  screens what LEDs did to the CRT. Small watch sized computing devices projecting their output on to foldable screens or holograms in the air will become the rage for those who cannot afford retina projection.

Both foldable and projection screens are becoming big within one year itself. Right call.

3. Handwriting and voice recognition will progresses and will acquire sophisticated learning capability to adapt to the user’s handwriting and voice. Galaxy note S pen like devices will become the input devices of choice by 2014.

Hasnt taken off - still waiting for better software. But many new pen based tablets have been a hit. So even steven on this prediction


4. As the benign nature of radiowaves becomes better recognized and less feared, using them to pick up brain activity will take off. With a combination of surface electrodes and electromagnetic probes, “thinking the word” will be converted into the word on a computer the same as handwriting recognition. First technology demonstrations will probably be ready by 2020 as an input device for the computer. Devices like Geordo la Forge’s visor will combine Bluetooth connections between wearable device in your pocket, earphone, retina projection and brainwave scanner for input device by 2020 and beyond.

No progress

5. The possibility of carrying on a conversation using brainwave input device and audio video output into earphone/retinal projection will take us further into AI linking humans and computers together seamlessly. Such conferencing of multiple personalities from many geographies with AI input on the topic will become possible. So talking to a client in USA by an Indian BPO operator can be done without the Indian accent and with computer support pulling up relevant data. Or a video conference between two world leaders will have input from generals and massively parallel AI to get real time data on say current status of global warming or tensions in Persian gulf. This will set the stage for the truly great thinkers to link their minds in a new way, leading to new ways of thinking and problem solving by 2030.

No progress

6. Three dimensional printing will become really big. And will become routine use in online shopping to get a touchy feely look.

It is taking off already

All of these predictions mean a complete change in the way we live starting from 2020 and becoming well integrated into life by 2030. Situation is similar to internet starting in late 1990s and completely changing our life by 2013 in 15 years time. Those who are unable to afford these new technologies will be left further behind = great danger for our country. These new devices will fall in price but it will take till 2030 to fall in price. This will maintain the productivity difference between the poor and the rich from now till 2030.

How to profit from it. Piling on to niche companies  can make you a lot of money. Look out for these and get in when the technology is still new and untested, before it becomes mainstream and everyone and his aunt know about it like . The next few years are a good time to watch out for such companies  – from recession and churning will always emerge the new wave of technological change.

Maintain this

Other technologies

1. Cars. Nothing new. Will become more expensive. Dont invest in US car makers.

Ford and GM are up 40%. Wrong call

2. Air travel. Nothing new. Will become much much more expensive. Dont invest anywhere.

The take off of Etihad is an interesting observation and needs further study - the nature of air travel might be changing and also the dynamics might be changing

3. Software. Trend will be bigger clouds. And smaller and more efficient apps. The trend of free software will continue to disrupt revenue streams. Like free AVG and Windows free antivirus etc eliminated the Norton antivirus, word excel and power point will get eliminated as open office like programs do everything for free. Similarly, free apps will eliminate the paid apps. The trend of people working for free to help other people will eliminate the need to pay big bucks for a software service – [B]internet has started the altruism change in people now rather than driven by self interest[/B]. ERP and data mining software will get simpler and cheaper off the shelf, reducing revenue. The principle of altruism will dominate the open source movement and eliminate the current leaders of paid software and paid clouds.

No progress

4. Viruses. Data elimination viruses will start disrupting life. At least one major hit by 2020 is likely. Will cripple financial data of a significant number of people and organizations (unlike individual hits currently). And this ruin some/massive number of lives. So don’t forget to have physical assets and hard copies of everything in case it is your demat or online account which gets wiped out.

Thank God this didnt happen yet. But it will.

5. Television. Internet TV will become routine pay per episode like Netflix. This is a big wave for the future and will destroy cable and satellite providers

No progress

Internet.

1. It will continue to simplify our lives and eliminate need for human interface.

2. Internet TV will become really big. You tube will becomes high definition pay tube and the default TV service in USA. The new generation wont know what is cable TV and what is dish TV. Sell media stocks in USA. I don’t know what to buy – maybe netflicks will get into online TV in a big way – you can read this up.

No progress

3. Getting revenue from internet will continue to challenge people as more and more free services will proliferate. Sell software product sellers.

Wrong call. Adobe up 50% from last year

4. Organized retail will stagnate and reduce as people start preferring the price advantage of online retail. Buy Amazon and Flipcart.

Amazon up 50% from last year. Right call.

Flipcart is replicating Amazon model of market dominance - but has haemorrhaged money. Anyway only private investors can get in

5. A few giants like a-pple, Microsoft and Google will be investing more and more into protecting their hardware requirements and get into backend integration of their hardware manufacturing. Software and hardware will merge again like IBM – separation of hardware and software will be a thing of the past. Wintel might become a new company merging Windows and Intel – but that depends on the success of Windows 8 and its projected tablet plus laptop devices. Cut throat competition means  S-amsung has to take over a software company (Google plus S-amsung = winning combination?) while  A-pple has to buy up Taiwanese manufacturers of its components. Microsoft will try to do it all in USA and import the people instead. This will benefit Indian techies from 2016 onwards. Sell Indian IT for now, buy after 2016 when body shops again come into vogue.

Wrong call - currency movements made it possible for a 40% return for Infosys and its brothers

6. The need for metropolitan cities bringing highly skilled people together will vanish. Downtown commercial real estate will not keep its value. The needless expense will be eliminated by the internet. While this possibility has been discussed for years, the present recession and cost cutting  will ensure its arrival. As the present generation becomes adult (generation Z) metropolitan life will decline in a big way. So sell REITS in USA. Buy logistics companies.

Dow all REITS is flat but with huge volatility up and down. 

Logistics up 25-50%

7. Urban infrastructure will change from being an agglomeration of skilled people into being transport, warehousing  and logistics hubs only. This will also reduce the need for long distance commuting and air travel. Buy shipping and air freight stocks. Sell airlines and car manufacturers.

Wrong call as earlier - but maintain my long term avoid on these sectors

8. Metropolises will no longer have the high paying jobs needed to support life there. This will start a trend of reverse migration and de-urbanization. No fresh construction will be needed. Sell construction majors. Buy truck and van manufacturers and rail road stocks.

Freight car up 10%. 

9. The cities of the future will change from being urban middle class productivity enhancers into being the playgrounds of the super rich. They will be the Las Vegases of the world. Pittsburgh, Chicago, Atlanta, Los Angeles and Detroit will decline. Manhatten will morph from being a center for finance professionals and become a center for the rich and famous. SanFrancisco Bay Area, Las Vegas, Reno, Phoenix and Miami  will regain their premium real estate valuations as the retirees move out and the super rich move in. Retirees will be forced to cash out their real estate equity from these places to sustain themselves. The rich will enjoy the good life here.

All these real estate destinations are up handsomely

10. Elsewhere, this trend will be maximum in London. It will become a playground for the rich from all over the world and as productive jobs get priced out from London because of the rich real estate valuations, the poor and the middle class will move away. Paris, Rome, Barcelona, Madrid and South of France will be other playgrounds of the rich. Germany is already seeing the small businesses of small towns prosper in the last 10 years and the trend will strengthen. London, Manhatten and San Francisco are the safest places in the West to buy up premium property on the cheap at current lower valuations, which are likely to maintain their super luxury tag. Las Vegas is also probably a safe long shot with dirt cheap valuations and massive growth potential. The best place for the same in the rest of the world are likely to be Beijing, Shanghai, Tokyo, Hong Kong, Macau, Singapore, Sidney, and Dubai. Dubai will re-emerge as the hot spot for the rich of the middle east and subcontinent. Good place to buy property on the cheap – best value buy.

London and Dubai performed spectacularly


11. Internet will continue to level the playing field between developed and backward countries. Buy into emerging markets.

Bad call - emerging markets tanked due to the threat of Fed taper

12. Financial companies will see major decline as internet banking and trading destroy them further. The present generation will get their tips from online info and buy and sell online. Brokers, financial companies and banks will see decline and loss of jobs.

Banks still thriving - wrong call

Sociology.

1. Major changes. The next generation Z will have grown up on the internet and social networks.

2. There will be a major decline in productivity of US people as the new generation Z loses skills to mechanical services of the internet. While the service itself will improve, the need for human input will reduce, making human effort less valuable.

Still maintain this

3. Education at higher levels will no longer deliver high paying jobs. Their value and fees charged will decline over the next 2 decades – because the fees has to be justified by the job you get by paying the fees. First trends will be visible by 2016. By 2020 even the ivy leagues will be in decline. Education will shift to the social network instead and will be cheap and available without influence of geographic location, social class or other such backgrounds. It will be the great leveller.

Happening right now and maintain this

4. Generation Z will be permanently stuck in lower skilled and lower paying jobs than generation Y. This will match their newer skills in online and social networked jobs, but will have less differentiation and less difference between one in USA and in developing countries.  Nobody will mind their lesser salaries, because the need for money will reduce because of higher efficiency.

Salaries for many jobs still very handsome in USA. CNN Money had a nice article on the well paying jobs - and with training people are still getting very good jobs.


5. There will be a reverse migration from cities into smaller peripheral communities which in turn will again force people into internet networked jobs.

Not yet

6. There will be an increasing trend of people helping each other without money – i.e altruism. People will be happy doing things just for the sake of it. This is increasingly seen in the free apps and free internet services like Wikipedia. This will reinforce the lower monetary compensation found acceptable by people. Helping each other will work better in smaller communities rather than in the big impersonal cities. So people with low pay in smaller villages will have a better life than people with low pay in big cities and hence reverse migration will be seen over the next 2 decades. Cities will dwindle, small cities will flourish. The recession in economy will precipitate this major trend starting from 2013, becoming a phenomenon by 2016 and being a massive trend by 2020.

Not yet - not by a long shot

7. As smaller towns and villages increase in population, many will get local clannish features. Many in USA will try to cut off from the rest of the world and lead more primitive lives. In the lower pay and less attractive life found in cities, many will find this regression acceptable. Enclaves such as this will be easier to maintain in isolation than in the last 20-30 years and many white supremacists and religious right extremists will form such enclaves. This again will reduce the general productivity of the USA per capita, as these backward thinking communities become unproductive and excluded from society.

No indication of this trend so far

8. The biggest reduction in productivity and pay in US will come from competition with the developing countries like India and China because of globalization.

Reverse of this trend because of Dollar appreciation - Americans still best paid and productive. Wrong call

9. The social networks will provide more emotional support and life will become more and more internet linked. This will again reduce the importance of money in giving satisfaction. The “likes” from online friends will replace money as a source of satisfaction for a free service provided – say a useful piece of software or an interesting story written or song sung.

Not yet

10. All of this means – reduction of money as the be all and end all of life, as we move towards a Star Trek like situation where there is no money. So the reduction in productivity, lower paying jobs and reduced importance for money will all come together over the next couple of decades to change life for the middle class as we know it.

Again - no signs of this happening

11. Class war with the new middle class and the super rich will be a big phenomenon. Middle classes will become massive in size, maybe 80% will be called middle class. They will be poorer than current Western middle class. Rich will form a smaller and smaller proportion as only the super rich will have survival advantage to sustain their richness. Class wars will then erupt. Movements of capital induced by such class wars will be a big thing changing the fortunes of many geographies.

No signs of this happening - in fact we seem to be getting more of the 20th century american phenomenon

12. By 2016 the stage will be set for the class war without people understanding the underlying economic reasons for the class war – because people are still thinking in the old ways. If the republicans win in 2016, then US will be the place for super rich. If democrats win, then there will be massive flight of capital from out of USA and into enclaves like Switzerland, London, Dubai and other money laundering economies. Hong Kong will be increasingly used by China to tap this floating capital in multiple ways – both as a vacation/residential destination and for funnelling capital into China. In other words, the role of Hong Kong in this regard, which has been traditional for last 100 years, will become more pronounced.

No signs of this happening

13. English will become the main world language displacing French and German permanently. Spanish and Chinese will be the only other languages.

I maintain this prediction

Medicine

1. Healthcare will continue to be expensive and as pay levels reduce, it will become more and more unaffordable. This means either a change in the education patterns to make medical education easier or accepting lower levels of pay by doctors.

No signs of this at all

2. Reduction of US medical education from 8 to 5 years is likely. This will also reduce the fee levels and the hardships involved in medical education.

No signs of this at all

3. As life dovetails into the principle of altruism, more and more medicine will be practiced for its noble nature like the physicians of 50 years ago and less and less for money. Since the patients will be unable to pay as before, this will be a self sustaining change.

No signs of this at all

4. So sell the expensive HMOs – but not immediately for many years since these are only long term trends. Also sell the big pharma – again not for many years. For now HMO and big pharma will do very well. Wait for changes – likely by 2016 if the democrats win. Otherwise by 2020. Buy into Indian generic pharma for short term and long term gains.

Lets wait and see

5. Drug development costs will have to reduce, since people wont be able to afford current costs. There will be fewer new drug developments. The progresses in medicine will reduce its pace over the next 2 decades

Very few new drugs and candidates. Fatigue in antibiotic discoveries. Maintain this prediction

6. At some point, brainy people will come together in the universities  and push a more altruistic model of medical discoveries like the physicians of a 100 years ago. The rewards of the work will be the knowledge of a job well done rather than monetary i.e. altruism again. This will also slow down the pace of medical and biology advances (since money is the best known motivator)

No signs of this at all

7. The complexity of human biology will require another 100 years at least to unravel – both because of the difficulty of the job and the reduced monetary rewards of doing so.

Maintain this

8. Human cloning will be attempted by breakaway societies in secret. Since it wont be the far right of USA (they are Christians), it is likely to be funded in secret in European or Chinese/Korean countries rather than USA. But by 2025 at least, the first human cloning attempt will be likely made and will cause massive furore. The complexity of the job being so great, it will be a crude attempt resulting in creation of a sick baby or clone with significant medical problems. It will likely result in greater efforts at policing. Successful human cloning is still a 100 years away at least.

No signs of this at all

Jobs: 

1. Significant changes in job trends will be seen in waves lasting a few years each, only to change into the next fancy as society evolves

Good evidence of changing job trends in USA

2. Current trend for next many years: Tech jobs and nursing

Right call

3. As people get used to lower salaries, manufacturing in USA will re-emerge as shipping costs from China will eclipse the local salary costs. This trend is likely by 2020. However, this will more likely be similar to small mill towns of the 20s and 30s – one factory supporting one town kind of situation. This is because the real estate costs of big cities cannot support manufacturing there. Learning these skills in anticipation will be wise for those in their childhood.

Happening as we speak

4. Sailors, truck drivers, fork lifts and delivery men will proliferate

No signs of this at all

5. Banks and financial jobs will keep on reducing

No signs of this at all

6. Real estate, construction, highrise, large scale glazing  jobs will keep reducing

No signs of this at all

7. As cities recede, many city level jobs like garbage men, water supply related jobs etc will reduce. In small towns, people will start doing these things themselves. They will cycle to work and do their own chores and dispose of their own garbage. Greater awareness of their carbon footprint will mean people will do these things out of choice and will be healthier and happier as a result.

No signs of this at all

8. Average per capita income of USA likely to reduce to 30,000 USD by 2020 and beyond. This is in terms of purchasing power since there will be an inflation event lasting a few years which will wipe out some 20-30% of USD purchasing power somewhere before 2020. Probably from 2016 to 2018 as the fed printing dies down. So even if per capita GDP is 50,000 USD, it will mean only 30,000$ in current terms. We have already seen this situation happening from 2000 to 2012 when per capita income grew less than the GDP growth figures – a disconnect due to globalization.

No signs of this at all - there is no evidence of inflation 

9. The trend of rich getting richer and poor getting poorer will change to the early 20th century pattern of very few super rich and massive poor / poorer middle class population by 2020-2025. The middle class will become massively middle – lower and upper middle classes will converge into one super group.

Majorly happening

10. Massive population in one social group will use political clout to cut the power of the super rich. This will lead to flight of capital. It will enrich emerging markets and enclaves like Switzerland. As productivity levels across the globe stabilise by 2030-2040, much of the capital will get destroyed as it gets used up in creating infrastructure in emerging markets. By 2030 there will be no enclave for capital to hide – like Swiss banks, channel islands, Bahamas etc. These places will get eliminated as the world converges into one giant super middle class, which is truly middle. By then the central bank fuelled excess liquidity situation would have extinguished itself and thus productivity will dictate the wealth levels.

No signs of this at all

11. Biggest jobs getting salary haircut: Realtors, finance, lawyers, university professors, doctors happening in that order from 2012 to 2040.

No signs of this at all

12. Jobs with increasing salary levels: school teachers, tech jobs, nursing, truck drivers.

Happened for Nursing and tech

13. Single biggest change will be management. The nature of top down management from central headquarters will shift to management of disaggregated workforce through social network based management. The number of middle level managers will decrease, and decrease massively. Thus reducing the cost of companies and also reducing the number of high paying jobs. Also, the few who are middle level managers will also become generic across many different sectors – commanding less salary. So a company selling shaving products online and a company managing a BPO and a software company online will all have their production teams. But subsequent levels of managers will have similar HR functions of ensuring employees meeting deadlines. They will be able to move across categories and their domain knowledge requirement will reduce. The nature of HR management will change for ever. Crossing of employees across different middle level management platforms of a single company, currently possible because of company based retraining and changing of responsibilities, will become much less. Instead, marketing, advertising, HR, company strategy, manufacturing will become even more dispersed in location as well as super specialized function. It is likely that pay levels of middle level HR management will be less than the productive employees with domain knowledge. Domain managers will be fewer than now and it will be difficult to move from lower to higher levels – most people will be stuck in the same job without salary increments.

No signs of this at all

14. Because of cross utility of management, conglomeration instead of specialization of companies will set in, creating MNC behemoths. There will be few managers in these conglomerates who will receive supra normal salaries and become super rich. Their functioning will also be network based and subject to cut throat competition. Super thinkers will be the only people who can survive this level of competition. Birth in rich family, education in the ivy league – these will lose their value as social networks destroy their value. The many first and second tier employees working from geographically diverse locations will remain stuck in their relatively lower paying jobs for ever. The companies themselves will remain more lean and efficient and hence more profitable.

No signs of this at all

15. A social network like management will mean there will be little difference between Atlanta, Seattle, Bucharest, Shanghai or Cudallore – as long as the person is capable enough. This globalization will also ensure lower pay for the US worker at the primary level – the primary level can be situated anywhere. It will also mean little difference between where the manager is located – the manager can be anywhere. Meetings will be in chatrooms because they are more productive than face to face – because decisions taken by a decision maker with considered inputs from his team is better than spur of the moment decisions driven by the decision maker face to face – where he has to worry about “saving face” and being decisive. Those who cannot take the right decisions will not be able to force the issue using authority of their position – and will lose their job.

No signs of this at all

16. The trend of social networks replacing management meetings will take quite a while to take place – it will happen when the generation Z is in their 40s and 50s. So by 2040 or 2050 only.

Politics:

1. Now that Democrats have won, there is likely to be zenophobia against immigration ( republican right) combined with anti-outsourcing (of the democratic left). At least one major legislation is likely which will impact our IT companies adversely.

Happened

2. Withdrawal of the US into itself will continue. Defence budgets will fall. An increasing participation of UK in global policing and decreasing US presence is likely. Leasing of aircraft carriers from USA to UK/Europe or by Arab dependencies is likely. A lot more of the role of Arab policeman will be played by UK – and Britannia will rule the waves once more. London will be settled by the super rich and this will boos the per capita GDP of UK to higher levels than France or even Germany by 2020 and 2030 respectively.

Happened

3. The limitations of drone warfare in policing jobs will become apparent. Those controlling the middle east oil will not be cowed down by drones like the Afghans – who are  unproductive tribals without oil or consequence. Iran and the restive populations of the Arab peninsula will not and cannot be controlled by drone attacks. So power projection will continue to require a blue water navy.

Drones evolved more and are multifaceted now - wrong call

4. Both US and Russia will continue and increase their role as arms suppliers of the world.

Happened

5. The chances of a major US strike against North Korea is now overwhelming. It is almost inevitable. Only question is when. USA simply cannot tolerate the possibility of a Korean nuclear strike against the US mainland or even Hawai. Only question is when.

Wrong call. But the situation is still evolving, the young un has killed his uncle. Who knows what comes next. Downgrading this possibility but still on watch

6. In the event of US strike on North Korea, South Korea and Japan will face a war and economic turmoil. The chances of these are quite high but should take 2-3 years to play out. A lot depends on whether this happens or not. If it happens, US presence on the Koreas will increase and so reduction of US forces based in Japan and reduction of US involvement in the region will not happen.

No signs of this at all

7. If north Korean war doesn’t take place, Japan will be increasingly asked to shoulder responsibilities by USA. Leasing of US carriers and nuclear subs by Japan and shift from US to Japanese soldiers in the Korean and South China seas will trend. This will be needed because of decrease in US participation, but bring  increased Sino Japanese tensions

Happening right now

8. Tensions of Japan vs China will increase surprisingly fast. This will necessitate shift of Japanese capital (largely routed to China through Taiwan) into South Korea and elsewhere to derisk political tensions. USA will increasingly look to Japan and South Korea as counterweight  to China because India has failed in this regard. Democrats will never trust India to do its duties.

Happened - including Democratic disdain for India as seen with the Devyani episode.

9. Return of Republicans in 2016 is likely. Since poor economics and immigration/outsourcing will be the main issues in the next election, republicans are likely to win. And for winning they will have to give up support for outsourcing.

Let us see

10. This time, both democrats and republicans are likely to have weaker candidates. Hillary will have a tough time if she runs and the republican candidate will be better matched. Hopefully, the republicans would have better candidates than their disastrous primary and the poor final selection in Romney. All of this means a close contest. A lot depends on how good a candidate the Republicans get – because if the candidates are equal, Republicans are sure to win.

11. Elsewhere, Cameron is likely to continue and a 10-12 year Conservative and assertive UK is likely. This will fuel London’s rise. If labour or liberals win, then London will rise less. Christian democrats are likely to dominate the Euro zone.

German elections happened as predicted

12. If the republicans return, expect US inflation to rise along with rising interest rates. Dollar will strengthen. US will finally exit the recession in 2018-2020.

13. If the democrats return, there will be permanent flight of US capital overseas and US will remain in recession.

Economics

1. I am changing my previous prediction of continuing immigration into USA fuelling growth. With my current thought process in favour of permanent reduction of productivity and increasing size of middle class in the 50,000 dollar per annum bracket, it is less likely that US will encourage more immigration. The lower returns on capital spent on higher education will also mean reduced levels of migration into US riding on US college education.

Wrong call - we are getting more of the same old stuff

2. Increasingly, same income levels in USA, Mexico, India and China at similar skill levels will inhibit migration. However, there will be continued migration at the highest levels in the 200,000 dollar pa levels of skill. Most migrations will be for the sake of shifting to a better area of law and order. Mostly this will be from people running from Mexican drug wars. From India, migrants will prefer Singapore, UK and Dubai, unless they are in the super bright category who can only get their level of work in USA. Germany and France will also try to attract the highest performers, in the face of UK’s ascent.

Maintain this

3. US economic output likely to remain stagnant in the absence of immigration. This trend will change only after 2020 or so (not in 2016 as in my previous prediction posted in 2010) – because the democrate won the 2012 election despite all odds because of poor quality candidates from republicans.

Wrong call - US growing now

4. Growth rates in US from 2012 to 2020 likely to be 2% on average, net of inflation. Sudden inflation in 2016-2018 is likely to wipe out the effect of this growth. So it better to say stagnant GDP of 15-16 trillion dollars.

USA grew 2% but no sign of inflation

5. Japan (5-6) and Euro zone (15-20 trillion) will also stay stagnant at current levels largely illo 2020 and beyond.

Japan and Euro growing slowly

6. China will grow at 7-8% reducing to 5-6% after 2020. So by 2020 it will be close to 10 trillion and by 2030 it will reach 20 trillion in output. Likely disruptions in pacific peaceful commerce and the effect of increasing oil prices are big caveats which can limit China to 15 trillion output levels – so 15-20 trillion is a safe range. Current projections for China by most commentators are more optimistic than this because they have extrapolated current rates of growth into the future without taking the effect of prolonged recession in US/Euro/Japan, geopolitical tensions and war like situations around China. They have also failed to account for oil price hikes in Brent and reduced requirement for manufactured products by West as well as emerging economies because of social changes reducing consumerism.

Let us see. Maintain this

7. Oil will shoot by 2014-2015 when despite global recession, the present overcapacity slack is completely taken up by Chinese and other Asian growth. Brent will increase much more than NYMEX  because of competition between Euro and China for the same oil. UK will try to substitute with north American oil by 2015 or so because of the disproportionate expenditure it will incur as it progressively takes over the role of global policeman from USA. Any wars will further aggravate this.

No signs of this at all

Global and US predictions for 2013

Fiscal Cliff = will be successfully climbed in congress. TRUE

Fed short term rate = same TRUE

Long term bonds = same for few months as fed easing continues, then rise to about 4% with a bond sell off (aggravated by tax rises for the rich causing flight of capital)

TRUE Major hit - I got the bond sell off right

Dollar index = around 80 for now, likely to reach 85-90 by second half. TRUE

Oil = 90 Nymex, 110 Brent for now. Fall to 80 Nymex and 100 Brent after bond sell off in second half

Minor miss - oil did fall after the bond sell off, but is back up to 97/110 levels

Dow 13000, fall to 12000 by year end  MAJOR WRONG CALL

Gold 1700 after fiscal cliff, fall to 1400 in second half  Major Hit - though it fell to 1200 on overshoot

FTSE = static for now, 6500-7000 by year end due to influx of capital into UK Hit

Dax fall to 6000 by year end as German growth slows Major Miss

SMI rise to 8000 by year end due to influc of capital into Switzerland  Hit

Cac fall to 3000 by year end due to poor growth  Minor miss

Nikkei static around 10,000 due to poor growth, 30% chance of 11-12000 due to stimulus effects Major Miss

Straits rise to around 3500 due to influx of capital Miss

Kospi rise to around 3500 due to excellent performance by Hyndai  Miss

Hang Seng steady around 22000-23000. Influx of capital and slowing China cancer each other out. Hit

Metals Fall due to recession Hit

Agri Commodities static due to good output Hit

Weather = mild, no extremes and no freak phenomenon affecting large areas Hit

Global Assets to buy/sell:

1. ING Global real estate fund after hardening of rupee is over. Short term effects seems to indicate good performance in New York and Hong Kong, although long term trend is down

30% up

2. Gold mining: Sell

Hit

3. Gold in dollars: Sell. Upside limited, downside unlimited

Hit

4. Global funds: sell. Limited upside, neutralized by the rising Rupee

Miss

5. Emerging market: Avoid. India is the best emerging market to invest in. China maybe you can keep Mirae CHina Advantage fund.

Hit

Note: Predictions for India will follow soon

Most of the predictions were general and long term. Some have happened, some have not - but still can.

I have changed my mind about change - it looks like more of the same will repeat for next few decades - change is slower than anticipated.

I majorly missed the US economic performance. 

I got the bond and gold calls very very right.


Indian Politics

1. Next general election will be held in 2014 only – congress will survive by whatever means possible because of poor performance expected in general elections

Happened

2. Maximum chances of third front coming to power after the elections. Followed by Congress with outside support. Last is BJP.

I am afraid I have to change election prediction - I will explain in the next years predictions for 2014. But chances of Congress forming govt are now nil 

3. Congress will lose seats in Maharashtra and Andhra. Also lose seats in Kerala, Rajasthan Happened and small states and side player states like West Bengal and Tamil Nadu. Will gain seats in Karnataka Happened.  It might gain to some extent in Madhya Pradesh Did not happen , Orissa, Chattisgarh Did not happen, Punjab and Jharkhand over current levels but not enough because mostly the home teams of NDA will still get the majority. Congress will lose or stay steady at current levels in Gujarat, Happened  Rajasthan Happened, Haryana, Bihar, (where BJP will win with allies, but not by big margins).

These were calculations for central elections, but clearly now the Congress will not gain in MP and CG and will be wiped out in Raj and Guj

4. Communists will win in Bengal Seems less likely now and Kerala but only slightly above the 50% mark. Will support third front.

5. Nitish Seems less likely now, Navin Patnaik, INLD Seems less likely now will win but might switch to third front. Naidu will lose. TRS will win and support third front for the sake of telengana Seems less likely now

6. Raman Singh, Chauhan, Raje will win Happened but only slightly above 50% Partly only true - MP and Raj were swept Raje result is is not sure either – not a good performer Did not happen.

7. Modi will win big  Happened and that will be the only big BJP win anywhere. Everywhere else they will limp home.

8. UP will see 50/50 split of SP/BSP and increased seats for congress because of muslims voting for congress in central election. BJP will lose. I am changing this prediction for next year 

9. Bihar will also see gains for congress at the expense of Laloo Yadav, again because of tactical voting by muslims. Nitish would still win big overall – so both Nitish and Congress will gain. Nitish might support the third front – but less likely than Navin who is sure to win and support third front.  I am changing this prediction for next year 

10. Maharashtra is likely to see NCP win big. MNS might ally with NCP and cause vote splitting. BJP and Shiv Sena might not gain much despite Congress losing a lot because of a quadrangular contest  MNS NCP alliance might support the third front. I am changing this prediction for next year 

11. Tamil Nadu and Andhra are too difficult to call as far as Congress is concerned and for who will gain more. Whoever wins might support third front.

12. Because of all this, BJP around 120-130 seats, Congress around 150 seats. That leaves a massive space for alliances.  I am changing this prediction for next year 

13. Chances of Third front 50%. Congress 30%, BJP 20%, depending on who stitched up the alliance and ultimate tallies.

 I am changing this prediction for next year 

14. Third front will crash both RE and stock markets. Hence my hesitation in recommending more investments into RE despite it being the investment of the decade – because RE is illiquid unlikje stocks.

Maintain this prediction. RE market already crashed. No fresh commitment to RE. I am changing my opinion regarding 3rd front being negative for stocks. I think Stocks will perform despite 3rd front govt.

Indian Sociology

1. Two main themes stand out. One is comprehensible. The other is incomprehensible.

2. What is for sure is that India is going to bypass the phase of urbanization. Better roads and communications mean that India will urbanize from the villages and small towns. This will propel the increase in rural productivity from 500 to 2000 dollars per annum from now till 2020 and then the further increase from 2000 to 5000 dollars per annum by 2030 and beyond. Given our genetic potential, 5000 dollars per annum probably reflects the peak productivity which can be attained by rural Indians. Including urban Indians, 10,000 dollars per capita is probably the best we can expect in the foreseeable future. This means a 5-10 times increase in productivity – a massive opportunity which will move us into Mexico/Russia/Brazil kind of situation.

Maintain above

3. What is difficult to get a handle on is what the street demonstrations caused by Anna and the recent rape case mean. Most likely is that the newer young people derived from rural migrations, backward castes and from children of lower middle class have a more angry and active personality. Very unlike the earlier upper middle class of mainly higher castes whose educated children only once came out in protests in the anti Mandal agitations – they are more meek and run away by emigration in adverse situations. Those who don’t have the option to run away will lead the future of urban India.

Best possible outcome of this incomprehensible phenomenon has taken place - in the form of AAP. I had no clue.

4. What it means. Our cities will not improve or become on par with cities of the West and East. Urban RE will remain scarce and sought after. Most people will not be able to afford ownership. Just like currently most people live in the urban villages of Delhi or the lal dora unauthorised colonies - at one third the cost, (or in the juggis of Mumbai), similarly the major part of our people will never live or work in cities. The small towns and villages will develop to the level of the outlying poor quality Delhi area. And stop there. Most of our population will live and work from such areas.

Maintain this

5. Big cities and the best apartments will be only for the rich and managerial class. Since the majority of our population is going to at best aspire to reach 10,000 dollars of per capita income i.e. 5 lakh rupees per annum, there is no way these masses will ever get to own decent urban dwellings.

Maintain this

6. But they will be able to afford good quality kothis in tier 2 and 3 cities where land is extremely abundant. The issue of land prices will be less important than the cost of construction. Inflation in the prices of iron, cement and tiles will make more difference than land prices. Since acreage of tier 2 and 3 cities is massively greater than in metros by orders of magnitude, land prices will not increase proportionately to land price increases in metros. The presence of good roads and proximity of infrastructure will determine the rise in land prices here. Blind increases as seen in metros will not occur. Instead increased in prices of bricks, cement and iron will make these houses increase in value – more directly linked to inflation than traditional tier 1 RE

Maintain this

7. There will be increased migration to the metros where jobs of a higher skill level will be available, but only to the really skilled. The stratification of society based on skill levels will become better ordered because of private sector. Competition for the best jobs, the best schools, the best homes and best locations will be intense and will propel further price rises in the metros. However, the price rises will be unaccompanied by increased quality of civic infrastructure.  Only scarcity value will increase.

Maintain this

8. Criminal activities by the less well off will increase manifold. Hence the rich will live in walled off areas with high security and increasing tendency to do their own chores because the personal servants will become increasingly unreliable. The best skilled people will leave the country because of these problems. Emigration will increase to 1980s levels (before the liberalization). This will reduce the numbers of the highest skilled people and hence there will be a continuous scarcity of ability (as seen today also – i.e. situation wont improve).

Maintain this

9. Honest people will be few and will be highly valued.

I am so happy to change this prediction - AAP has demonstrated that there is space and availability of honest people - and they are there in the thousands and lakhs and crores - so future of India is bright. 

I said above in Dec 2013. But it looks like Kejriwal was not honest after all - only pretending to be honest. So Maintain Prediction in March 2014

10. The high cost of both real estate and transport will change the workplace location from company oriented to neighbourhood oriented common e-offices. Hubs for offices common to multiple companies will take off – now because the conditions demand it rather than 10 years ago when it was first mooted. Both connectivity and improved office plates in commercial RE (otherwise lying empty) will also help in the transition, as also the traffic congestion, road rage and lack of law and order and safety.

Not happened yet - but has to happen

11. So a person will clock into his or her local e-office, regardless of whether he works for Wipro/Infosys or GE. He will log his lap top into a LAN and start working. No driving, no Sumo cabs and no safety problems. So person living in Yamuna Expressway will not need to transport himself to his work – his workplace will be just around the corner and he could work for a company in Bangalore or San Francisco. But the e-office will ensure better discipline than the outsourcers/body shoppers working from home (currently) and will be preferred by companies as being next best to physical presence.

No signs of this happening


12. The local e-office will evolve into a commerce hub integrating office spaces with connectivity, eating out and crèches for female employees. They will have swipe cards to keep employees on the clock, phones for making calls, office automation and courier services. Females will prefer this for its safety and time saving.

No signs of this happening


13. Companies will gain in reducing their real estate need, office infrastructure needs and also pay less – for the time and cost of transport saved by the employee, company will pay lesser salary. Both employees and companies will gain.

No signs of this happening


14. This trend will first start from USA as cities dissipate to smaller towns and village communities, as discussed earlier. The management software will be built there, modelled around social networks. And then get transported to India in a big way because conditions will require it. Starting 2016 and culminating 2020.

No signs of this happening. It might happen only in India - since in USA more of the same seems to be on the cards.


15. This trend will also kill the big commercial buildings – or they will sell at lower prices and lower rent. Any further increases in commercial property prices will be met with lack of occupancy – businesses cannot afford such RE prices.

This has happened - all commercial RE is in big trouble because unaffordable.

16. Only those who catch these trends earlyand modify their locations and type of buildings being built – the service levels installed and whether it is close to big pockets (of people not wanting to commute) – like Greater NOIDA, Yamuna Expressway, Bhiwadi and Dwarka Expressway – will determine success of commercial buildings.

Maintain

17. Life will change for ever in these disruptive ways.

No signs of this happening


18. E-commerce will kill the local durable store. Real estate costs mean they can never match flipcart prices. Phones, refrigerators, washing machines, lap tops and every other kind of toy and gadget will now be ordered and delivered on line – and even cars in the more distant future. The need for warehousing by dealers will reduce inventories and also the heavy real estate costs – with great savings in prices passed on to consumers as well as retained by the manufacturer. There will be demonstration shops in malls for looking at the item – there will be specialization of these malls – say one giant mall where every durable company will demo its products. Purchase will be online with credit cards. This will kill salesman jobs in large numbers as the need to pay commission based remunerations will also go to the company bottom line. Instead, screen presentations of features and benefits of the product in comparision to the competitors will be accessed online through youtube presentations while the person looks at the product and gets its feel. Or he will access you tube on his own tablet. Barcodes on the products will help in retrieving the more specific models – through the  bar code scanner. Everything else will be online retail.

No signs of this happening although Flipcart and OLX are slowly changing India


19. Organised retail will change the food and clothing retail models for ever – this is well discussed in newspapers already, so wont discuss.

No signs of this happening


20. Law and order: Major challenges exist in this area. It is necessary to recruit people from college educated background into police force. And import police trainers from Western countries to run a modern police force. If our politicians are able to understand this, then things will get better.

No signs of this happening but hopefully AAP will initiate it


21. I expect political failure in this regard. So law and order will degenerate. There will be complete chaos in the small towns. People will try to escape to cities but face the same problems because the law breakers will also head there. The super rich will try to wall themselves in enclaves and try to escape the law breakers. Prices of properties having good security, good CCTV and guard systems will be very high. Those townships with poor security will not get preferred.

This has happened in UP, Muzaffar Nagar, Naxal areas, MP. But politics has a new hope in the form of Luke Kejriwal Skywalker. The Jedi might return !!! 

March 2014 - But looks like he was Anakin Skywalker and turned into Darth Vader

22. Increasingly, self sufficient townships where everything including jobs, entertainment, schools, colleges and hospitals will be preferred. Standalone projects where commuting is required will be less preferred. It will matter little whether the township is in Delhi, Jaipur, Shimla or a village on a highway – as long as people within have the money to procure security and broadband connectivity for themselves. Those projects without security will be abandoned.

No signs of this happening


23. Mumbai  and Bangalore are more likely to have better security than Delhi. In the long run, these places will win over Delhi.

No signs of this happening - with AAP, future looks brighter for Delhi


Economics

1. India will not grow to developed country levels. Maximum peak productivity is probably 10-15000 dollars per capita per annum by 2050.

Maintain

2. Continuous emigration of the highest productive people to foreign countries in search of better security and law and order will cripple India’s increase in prosperity – as the highest productive class continuously bleed out.

Happened in Dubai over last year

3. Roads will develop little from 2013 to 2016, because of the increased capital required and tendency of Congress and Socialists  to spend on populist rather than productive schemes.

Happened

4. One episode of flight of foreign capital is bound to happen when a crisis of confidence is reached. This is most likely to be in 2014 before elections.

Already happened

5. Dollar should appreciate to 60 and beyond during the flight of capital.

Happened

Since the Western economies are also likely to be moribund and poor destination for our exports, this collapse of Rupee is likely to be sudden, drastic and cause enormous stress. A good anticipation by present economists and proper preventive action can greatly reduce the effects – but so far the govt. does not inspire confidence.

Happened - including govt incompetence

6. At this time of currency collapse, inflation is likely. Mostly, it is likely to be imported inflation pushing up the cost of capital, steel, oil and finished products like cars and gadgets.

Happened

7. Gold outperformance is likely to be linked to this period of rupee depreciation and inflation. During this time, Gold should give good returns. It will be better than real estate for 1-2 years just during this time. Most likely time is in 2014. So selling stocks and buying gold should work at this time. After 2016 or so, gold should fall a lot in both Rupees and in dollars. Gold will cease to be important as an asset class after the rupee depreciatin event and the US inflation event. Both expected to be over by 2016-2018.

Gold was steady in Rupee terms even as it fell in dollars - and from 25000 it went up to 31000 before falling again, during the Rupee collapse of 2013


8. FDs will give stable returns going forward, because central bank will not be able to lower interest rates.

Happened

RBI and FD rates will have to rise a lot in the 2014 period when dollar will increase in value and there will be flight of capital.

Happened

You should not be in bonds at this time because bond funds will fall a lot.

Happened

Lowering of rates by RBI from 2016 onwards as the markets stabilize should make bond funds give great returns from 2016 onwards.

Maintain and bringing forward this prediction

9. Stocks will respond to even the half hearted measures taken by the govt and should beat the FD returns in 2013 till 2014.

Stocks gave 9% and select sectors like IT, FMCG outperformed. So stocks gave as much return as FD - but since there was little downside risk and upside potential was not fully realised because of bad budget and tax/spend policies of govt and total mismanagement - with better management, stock would have given 20% easily

There is likely to be a major disruption in stock market in 2014 because of coming together of many factors both internal and external. From 2016, stocks should outperform.

Downgrading this possibility and bringing forward the stock outperformance

10. RE in NCR should be stagnant till 2014

Happened

followed by a liquidity crisis as massive deliveries in NCR and pulling out of capital by NRIs fearful of currency crash – causing chaos.

Happened to a smaller extent - it was handled better because it came earlier rather than in 2014

Many projects will be undelivered or abandoned and many builders will go belly up.

Thankfully not yet and might be avoided altogether since the disruptions were less harmful

This disruption should last 2-3 years at least.

Maintain

Prices of UC property will collapse.

Only stagnation because came early

 But RTM prices will rise because of scarcity value and because nobody will want UC property and all will try for RTM.

Happened in NOIDA and Gurgaon but not in Delhi

People who pull out of stocks in time will be sitting on cash and will be able to buy the RTM.

Did not happen because stocks did not perform as expected

Those hurt in the stock crash will not be able to buy into the crash. Net net, deals in even RTM will dry up because of the doom and gloom feeling. Those planning to sell in this time should anticipate such possibilities.

Maintain

Predicting the rest of India’s decade assuming no wars:

1. Stocks outperform in 2013.

Happened

Buy stocks now.

Good advice

Keep 30% in FD/bond funds to benefit from 8% plus returns.

Good advice

Hold RE.

Good advice

Sell gold

Good advice

, global funds and other dollar denominated assets.

Bad advice - because the crash of Rupee expected in 2014 came early in 2013 - because I expected taper in 2014 but the "THREAT" of taper in 2013 caused all the harm - more harm than actual taper

2. Sell stocks and bonds in 2014 beginning. Buy gold. Hold RE.

Bad advice because stocks never outperformed or went to 25000 and the taper is behind us. Dont buy gold because the need was when Rupee had gone to 68. RE there is no option except to hold

3. Wait out 2014, 2015 and 2016 H1, riding on gold and RE.

Changing this soon in 2014

4. Sell gold when inflation gets over in USA, probably when republicans return to power after 2016. Buy bonds at their peak interest rate levels around the same time

Changing this soon in 2014 

5. Switch from bonds to stocks as the India and global crisis dissipates.

Maintain

6. Hold stocks for a phenomenal bull run from 2018 to 2020 and beyond. Switch to new bookings in RE from 2016 – 2017 or so – keeping the new trends of townships, jobs etc as detailed above in mind.

[B][COLOR="blue"]Maintain[/COLOR][/B]

7. Sell current holdings in RE in 2022 and beyond, at the cusp of the RE bull run which will follow the stock bull run. So 10 year holding period.

Maintain

If war starts before 2014:Did not happen
1. Abort the stock and bond holdings immediately. Shift from bonds to FD and gold. Hold RE.

2. If war starts between 2014 and 2016, it will accentuate the above cycle effects. Ride it out by shifting from bonds to FD, hold current RE holdings and make fresh gold purchases.

Downgrading risk

3. Likelihood of wars in the vicinity are maximum from 2014 to 2016.

Maintain

4. My previous prediction of Iran China pipeline have so far failed to materialize. Economics indicate overwhelming likelihood of this happening but it hasn’t so far, despite deployment of missiles by China in tunnels of Aksai Chin. So I am downgrading this as a flashpoint for war.

Iran is not a flashpoint, but India Tibet border remains a bigger flashpoint as everyone knows

5. US engagement of Pakistan continues to be effective. So complete abandoning of USA by Pakistan and switching to China also has become less likely. Again downgrading this possibility.

Upgrading this possibility since US withdrawing from region. Major nuclear cooperation for China Pakistan underway

6. Complete degeneration of Pakistan into chaos is also not happening. That is the third major possibility that I am downgrading from predictions made 2 years ago.

Maintain

7. Main flashpoint seems to be US bombing of North Korea and subsequent efforts by Iran to prevent similar bombing.

Did not happen but recent execution of Kim uncle might presage a major policy blunder by Korea

8. US seems to be having a wait and watch attitude. In Iran, waiting for pro-democracy forces to topple the regime or reduce its extremist tendencies, based on internet penetration and social networking. In North Korea, waiting for economic collapse similar to Russia. And in Pakistan, waiting for the Jehadi madness to abate in the minds of the masses.

US is succeeding

9. So far, above US strategy seems to be working. Most likely, North Korea will be the first to try US patience.

Maintain

Predictions for 2013

1. Stocks up. Possibly 25% return can be expected. Sensex 25000. Main propelling drivers will be some governance improvement and US climbing over the fiscal cliff (happened already after I wrote this) and unleashing another round of liquidity. Stocks should remain steadily up throughout from now till 2014 budget at least. SIP should continue and any dips should be used to buy.

9% - but full potential was 25%. I had already changed this prediction after budget. It was not my mistake but PC's mistake 

2. Best sectors: cyclical and infrastructure, construction, cement, banks.

Major miss - but I had posted follow up that FMCG was better after budget

3. Avoid: FMCG and durables because of saturation and belt tightening and overvalued share prices.

Major miss - but I had posted follow up that FMCG was better after budget

4. Bonds: Mild 0.25 % fall in Repo rates is the best that can be expected. RBI unlikely to reduce further. Returns are not enough to justify eschewing stocks in favour of bonds – so if you are overweight bonds, sell now and shift to stocks.

Good advice

5. FD: Returns of 8% plus will continue. Best safe and high returns available. At least 30% should be here or in PF.

Good advice


6. Real estate: Stagnant markets are likely. No need to increase exposure at this juncture – but also no need to sell existing investments – hold what you already have.

Good advice


7. Best RE market (for those underexposed to RE currently) for 2013 is likely to be Bangalore,

Good advice

Chennai, Chandigarh, Bhubaneshwar and certain locations of Mumbai

Bad advice 

– although 2014 will be better for Mumbai than 2013 on the back of good stock market performance.

8. Steady markets will be Gurgaon flats, NOIDA extension, Jaipur, Lucknow, Coimbatore, Mangalore, Kolkata, most of Mumbai, Pune and Dehradun.

Good advice


9. Falling or steady with slight downward trend type of markets will be in NOIDA central, Kundli, Delhi builder floors and Lal Dora, Gurgaon plots, Dwarka expressway, NOIDA expressway, Yamuna Expressway, Faridabad, Bhiwadi/Daruhera, Neemrana.

Good advice


10. Gold: Stagnant prices. Rupee strengthening will wipe out the returns of the fiscal cliff being climbed.

Good advice


11. Dollar: Weak at 51-53 levels for most of the year.

Bad advice because Rupee collapsed. Dollar denominated investment out performed

12. Oil: Weak. NYMEX 85-90. Brent 100-110. Not much movement

Good advice


13. RBI repo: maximum 0.25% cut.

Repo back to square 1 almost

Caveats:

1. Govt falls. This will kill the Rupee, Real estate and stock markets. Gold will shoot up. Same effect as war = do the same things, sell stocks, bonds and buy gold.

I should have said govt FAILS instead - because all these happened because of bad governance.

2. War involving us, Pak, China, South Korea, Argentina or Iran: Same results as above.

ASSETS FOR INDIA:

Asset of 2013 = stocks Hit

Asset of the decade = Real estate

Asset of the next 3 decades = stocks

Asset to avoid in 2013 = gold.  Hit

Asset to avoid in the next decade = gold.  With 2014/15/16 being short term exception as detailed above. You can avoid gold altogether and ride out disturbances in FD plus RE also.

Asset to avoid in next 3 decades = gold. It will extinguish as asset after 2018 or so.

Value is what humans place on a thing – if a thing is prized, it is priced high. If a thing is no longer prized, it will not be priced. Not even gold.

Looking back, I got a lot of directions right - but my main mistake was that I expected taper in 2014 and the THREAT of taper did the same damage in 2013 - unpredictable.

But the exercise does demonstrate that while specifics cannot be predicted, broad directions, asset of the year, asset to avoid for the year - these broad trends are mainly predictable and can help one to plan shifts in asset allocation. The exercise is therefore still useful - it is entirely possible to get all the specifics wrong and still catch the best assets for the year - as long as proper diversification / allocation methods are still followed.